Electricity auction to begin Tuesday

As rate freeze set to expire, process will shape bills

Monday, September 4, 2006

By Adriana Colindres
Copley News Service

SPRINGFIELD - The size of many Illinoisans' future electricity bills will hinge largely on the results of an auction-style process that gets under way Tuesday.

At this point, though, much remains unknown.

For instance, no one can pinpoint how long the so-called "reverse auction" will last. It could go on for days. And translating auction results into meaningful information for consumers will take some extra time once the auction ends.

Also uncertain is how many bidders will turn out. More than 20 qualified bidders have taken the necessary steps to become eligible, but they don't have to participate. Their identities are secret.

Further, the reverse auction will deal with only the price of electricity after Dec. 31, not the price of delivering power to homes and businesses. The price that utility companies Ameren Corp. and Commonwealth Edison may charge for delivery has yet to be decided by the Illinois Commerce Commission. Delivery charges presently make up about 20 percent to 30 percent of a total electricity bill.

Higher bills

Despite the unknowns, one thing seems clear: Electricity bills will rise significantly starting next year for customers of Chicago-based ComEd and St. Louis-based Ameren, which in Illinois includes AmerenIP, AmerenCIPS and AmerenCILCO.

Estimates of the increase so far have ranged from 20 percent to 60 percent or more for Ameren customers.

The auction is taking place because a 1997 state law that restructured the electricity industry also imposed a rate freeze for customers of Ameren and

ComEd. The freeze will expire at the end of this year.

The utility companies' power-purchase agreements with electricity suppliers also will expire at the end of 2006. Under the 1997 restructuring law, utilities could get rid of their power-generation capabilities while keeping the job of delivering electricity to customers. Ameren, for instance, created a separate affiliate for generation.

The auction that begins Tuesday will have no direct impact on people who buy electricity from cooperatives or from municipally owned entities, such as Springfield's City Water, Light and Power.

How it will work

The two utility companies hired NERA Economic Consulting to manage the bidding process in Illinois. NERA has handled similar auctions elsewhere.

Keeping a close eye on the auction will be staff from the Illinois Commerce Commission and from Boston Pacific Co., which is the auction monitor. The ICC is the state's utility regulator.

An office in Chicago will serve as a sort of "mission control" for the auction, but bidders will not physically be there. Rather, the bidders likely will operate from their respective home offices, from where they will submit bids electronically with software specifically tailored for the purpose. Backup systems will be in place that would allow for bids by fax or phone.

The Chicago office will be accessible to only about 16 or 17 people from NERA, the ICC and Boston Pacific, said the ICC's Tom Kennedy, who is one of the select few. The room, secured by a door with an electronic lock, has been swept for electronic "bugs" at least a couple of times.

When the auction starts Tuesday morning, the auction manager will open bidding at a specific price for each of the two main sections: for "fixed price" products, which are those used by most residential customers and some other types of customers, and for service priced to the "hourly" market.

Prospective power suppliers will submit bids to supply a portion of the electricity load. Each portion is called a "tranche" and consists of roughly 50 megawatts. The fixed-price portion of the auction will have 510 tranches, and the hourly portion will have 90 tranches, according to NERA.

Bidders already have been certified as eligible to bid for a certain number of tranches.

If the bidders offer to supply more tranches than are needed, the auction manager will lower the bid price and another round of bidding will begin. The process repeats itself as long as there is an excess supply of tranches. Bidding will end, and prices will be set, when the number of tranches that are bid is the same as the number needed.

"To some extent, we hope (the auction) will last a fair amount of time because the longer it lasts, the more prices are ticking down," said Kennedy, manager of the policy program in the ICC's energy division.

The auction includes safeguards meant to ensure a competitive bidding process among the prospective electricity suppliers. For example, if a bidder makes a first-round submission for 25 tranches, he or she may not try to submit a larger bid in a later round.

"That keeps the bidders from kind of playing games by taking bids out and then adding them back in," Kennedy said. "They're always limited to the amount of tranches they had in the last round."

Reviewing results

Within a few days of the auction's conclusion, the ICC will determine whether the auction had a "successful result" or whether an investigation is warranted.

Assuming the auction is deemed successful, the ICC and/or the utility companies should release some information by the end of September that explains what the auction results will mean for consumers.

In addition, ICC staff and the auction manager are to write public reports with more-detailed information about the auction. Those should be issued by Dec. 1.

The auction process, which all five members of the Commerce Commission approved in January, nonetheless has attracted criticism.

The Citizens Utility Board, a utility watchdog group, has qualms about being excluded from the secure Chicago office where ICC staff and others will track the auction.

"One of our frustrations is there's no consumer representative in the room while the auction is being conducted," said David Kolata, executive director of CUB. "We're going to do the best we can to monitor this and then respond accordingly."

Attorney General Lisa Madigan has gone to court to try to stop the auction, but her efforts haven't paid off to date.

Her view is that an auction will violate the state Public Utilities Act because the law forbids utility companies from charging market-based rates to customers who have no choice about which company provides their electricity. Despite the intentions of the 1997 electricity restructuring law, no competitive market has developed for residential customers, and most Illinoisans still must purchase power from their local utility company.

Madigan also believes the auction results will deal an especially harsh financial blow to Ameren customers. Benjamin Weinberg of Madigan's office said Ameren historically has charged less for electricity than ComEd, but the auction will set the same price for both.

Kennedy of the ICC said that isn't necessarily the case. While the auction theoretically could result in identical prices for individual products offered by both companies, "there's no reason for it," he said.

Madigan, however, remains skeptical.

"Ameren customers will be hit with much larger increases in their electric bills than ComEd customers (as a result of the ICC's decision to allow utilities to purchase electricity through an auction)," she said in an e-mailed statement. "That's not fair, and it is not what the General Assembly intended when it authorized deregulation in 1997."

More information about the auction is available online at www.illinois-auction.com.

Adriana Colindres can be reached at 217-782-6292 or adriana.colindres@sj-r.com.