Madigan: Power auction unfair

Attorney general asks court to void results

Tuesday, September 19, 2006

BY MIKE RAMSEY
OF COPLEY NEWS SERVICE

CHICAGO - Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan on Monday asked the state appellate court to reject the results of the recent power auction that will trigger massive electric rate increases on Jan. 2.

Also on Monday, the Citizens Utility Board (CUB), the state's largest energy watchdog group, filed a brief with the appellate court, arguing the plan is illegal and hits consumers with unfair market prices at a time when the power companies still hold a monopoly on residential services.

Madigan, who earlier went to court to try to stop the power auction, said the Illinois Commerce Commission lacks authority to approve market-based rates for electricity "because the market does not yet offer competitive choices," meaning that most Illinoisans still have to buy electricity from their local provider.

"We learned last Friday what prices come from the auction, and the attorney general doesn't believe these prices are reasonable, especially for AmerenCILCO customers," said Benjamin Weinberg, chief of the public interest division in Madigan's office.

AmerenCILCO provides most electric service for the Peoria area and much of central Illinois.

Meanwhile, Republican gubernatorial nominee Judy Baar Topinka is blaming Democratic Gov. Rod Blagojevich for the massive rate hikes.

Topinka, who trails the incumbent by 30 percentage points in a new Chicago Sun-Times poll, said Blagojevich appointees on the ICC green-lighted the power auction and approved its results. Ameren announced that average residential rates for some of its downstate customers will increase 55 percent to reflect market and delivery costs when a nine-year, state-imposed electric-rate freeze expires Jan. 1; ComEd estimated its residential bills in the Chicago area would rise about 22 percent.

"These are (Blagojevich's) hand-picked, rubber-stamp ICC nominees that run this thing," Topinka said at a news conference on another topic. "They're the ones that have carried out his will. He has not interacted with them, and if he has, this is what we have. And we are going to have high electrical prices because of that."

Topinka said she would support legislation extending the Illinois rate freeze or other efforts to control rate increases.

Blagojevich picked four of the ICC's five commissioners in his first term, though the regulating entity is supposed to function independently of the governor's office. His campaign spokeswoman, Sheila Nix, said Blagojevich opposed the power auction and also backs a rate-freeze extension. Nix said the governor will push the General Assembly to send him such a measure in the November veto session.

She criticized Topinka for not aiding Blagojevich's efforts last year to appoint consumer advocate Martin Cohen as ICC chairman. The Senate blocked his choice, with some lawmakers doubting Cohen's ability to be impartial in rate cases.

"When she has an opportunity to actually do something and play a leadership role, she stays silent, and then after the fact, she starts being critical," Nix said.

St. Louis-based Ameren last week said AmerenCILCO's average monthly residential bills in the Peoria region will increase by 55 percent, or about $33, while AmerenCIPS and AmerenIP monthly residential bills will increase by 40 percent, or about $26, under the new fixed-price system.

Ameren says it will ask lawmakers for permission to phase in the post-auction rate increases while charging customers a financing fee.

State lawmakers imposed the soon-to-expire electric rate freeze in the late 1990s as part of a deregulation of the industry. Critics say the power auction, conducted earlier this month, was a bad idea because a true competitive marketplace has not materialized for power companies to buy electricity from suppliers. The ICC unanimously approved the auction system, but a spokesman said the resulting electricity rates still must meet with the panel's approval.

David Kolata, Cohen's successor in running the Citizens Utility Board, said the watchdog group supports a continued rate freeze or some method of mitigating increases for consumers.

Topinka's criticisms about Blagojevich and the ICC came as she proposed a health-care package that would give Illinois women better access to mammograms and the vaccine that can prevent cervical cancer. Topinka, a third-term state treasurer from Riverside, said the enabling legislation would make insurance companies shoulder more costs.

Also Monday, Topinka dismissed results of a Chicago Sun-Times/NBC5 poll that suggested Blagojevich leads her 56 percent to 26 percent. She said it is far out of line with other recent polls that indicate the gap is much smaller.

"I would question the methodology," Topinka said of the new poll. "I'm not concerned about it. This is going to be a tight race right to the end and, frankly, I still think that ultimately you will see the public has a significant choice to make here, a great difference between candidates."

Topinka squares off against Blagojevich, a Chicago Democrat, in the Nov. 7 election. A third gubernatorial nominee, Green Party candidate Rich Whitney of Carbondale, also is on the ballot.

Mike Ramsey can be reached at (312) 857-2323 or cnsramsey@aol.com. Adriana Colindres of Copley News Service and the Associated Press contributed to this report.