City faces 'hard decision'

Wednesday, September 20, 2006

BY JENNIFER DAVIS
OF COPLEY NEWS SERVICE

PEORIA - Should Peoria build a new upscale hotel connected to the Civic Center to help bolster its ongoing $55 million renovation and expansion?

A Chicago consultant won't say.

"We're not going to tell you what to do - build it or don't build it," said Tom Hazinski, managing director of HVS Convention, Sports and Entertainment Facilities Consulting. However, "doing nothing has consequences."

Basically, HVS believes the city has two choices: use public money to help build a new upscale hotel connected to the Civic Center or use public money to help with major renovations to the Holiday Inn City Centre.

"I think it's a hard decision. You have competing concerns," Hazinski told the City Council on Tuesday while presenting its market study. "Not everyone is going to come away happy."

The Peoria Civic Center is doubling its convention space. The city doesn't have enough quality hotel rooms to match that, in large part because of problems at the City Centre, HVS says.

The consultants noted problems with inadequate hot water and air conditioning as well as stained carpets and worn furniture. The Holiday Inn City Centre, which officials there say is in line for some upgrades, is also for sale, listed at $13 million.

Meanwhile, an Embassy Suites hotel with connected conference center is under construction in East Peoria - an upscale new player expected to siphon away Civic Center business.

HVS estimates a three- or four-star hotel connected to the Civic Center will cost $33 million, or about $132,000 per room. It will take some public subsidy, which has not yet been not estimated.

"They're (other hotels) not being built without (public subsidy), and this hotel will not be built without it," Hazinski said. "It's just a fact of the market today."

At the same time, he adds: "The Holiday Inn has to be dealt with. (Improving) it would be one way to improve the supply, though not as well as an attached Civic Center hotel would."

The City Council listened to HVS' presentation but took no action Tuesday.

"If or when there is an offer on the table (from a developer), then I'm sure the council will have quite a bit of discussion," Mayor Jim Ardis said.

Still, some council members made it clear Tuesday where they stand.

"Peoria just recently lost a Christian convention, which would have generated over 8,500 room nights. Their main concern was they wanted an attached hotel," said At-large Councilman Eric Turner, who serves on the Peoria Area Convention and Visitors board. "This (new) hotel is needed. We need a long-term vision so we can increase our economic vitality."

At-large Councilman Chuck Grayeb, who is also liaison to the Civic Center, was absent Tuesday, but he also has supported a new hotel.

But At-large Councilman Gary Sandberg, who didn't support the expansion of the Civic Center, was critical of the study, especially after learning HVS didn't study the impact of the Civic Center's last expansion in 1995. That expansion also doubled the convention space.

"If you're off, everyone takes it in the shorts in a big fashion," Sandberg said.

Jennifer Davis can be reached at 686-3282 or jdavis@pjstar.com.