![]() Suspects' bitter plot led Chandler to her deathThursday, September 21, 2006 By John Tunison The Grand Rapids Press HOLLAND -- As their anger and jealousy mounted toward the pretty night clerk at the Blue Mill Inn, a group of security guards living there plotted to "teach her a lesson," court documents show. That lesson would include a night of rape, torture and murder, an evening that remained a secret for 27 years as those responsible scattered to other states and went on with their lives, police said. The disturbing scheme -- set against a backdrop of sexual promiscuity among guards, inn employees and female industrial workers -- is outlined in an affidavit that details what police say is the long-unknown motive for Janet Chandler's murder 27 years ago. "It was known by most, if not all, that Janet was not going to be coming back," Michigan State Police Detective David VanLopik said of the planning among guards, their female friends and Chandler's female work supervisor. VanLopik's 10-page affidavit exposes a world of seedy sexual exploits at the Blue Mill Inn that culminated in the calculated killing of the 23-year-old Hope College student on Jan. 31, 1979. The document was used to obtain arrest warrants this week for five people who have tried to lead normal lives in four states, but who harbored a secret, police and witnesses say. Charged with murder are former Blue Mill Inn manager Laurie Swank, 48, and four guards: Arthur "Carl" Paiva, 54; Anthony Williams, 55; Freddie Parker, 49; and James Nelson, 59. Paiva, in a Wednesday interview, denied allegations he raped Chandler and told her "You're going to die." "I always wondered what happened to Janet," the Muskegon man said from the Allegan County Jail. "I saw a documentary (about the killing) on television and was happy they were reopening the case. I never in all this time thought the guards were involved. "If I knew anything about it, I would have reported the information right away. I was at management level. I wasn't part of the crowd," he said. Police however, claim Paiva and other guards were among those at a "planning session" at the Blue Mill Inn office on U.S. 31. There they allegedly hatched a scheme to abduct Chandler from the inn, take her to a guest house on Chemtron property, and gang-rape and kill her. Swank, Chandler's supervisor, is accused of being an instigator. According to the affidavit, Chandler was "intimate" with some of the Wackenhut Security guards who were staying at the inn while working at the strike-bound Chemtron Corp. in nearby Holland Township. In fact, several guards had relationships with inn employees and female Chemtron employees that were "non-monogamous," the affidavit states. "It has been learned that in the process of these relationships, there grew intense anger and jealousy toward Janet Chandler, by the guards, which also was driven by other females who were associated with this group of security guards," according to the court document Chandler's nude body was found dumped in a snowbank in the Int. 196 median near Covert in a crime initially thought to be a robbery and abduction at the inn. First arrest in February But early this year, after a two-year probe, a team of "cold-case" police investigators began exposing details behind her death with the February arrest of former guard Robert Lynch, 67, of Three Oaks. "The allegations here are as shocking and disturbing as ever I have seen," state Attorney General Mike Cox said Wednesday at a press conference to announce the five additional arrests. "Her boss participated by inciting and encouraging the men to do what they did to 'teach her a lesson.' This was a murder motivated by jealousy, envy and just plain meanness." Swank lived with Chandler at a house on Holland's north side, but was not a Hope College student. She allegedly verbally berated Chandler as she was sexually assaulted and physically beaten with a belt, according to the affidavit. The affidavit says Chandler was abducted by trickery after Nelson and Lynch told her they were having a surprise party for her. Suspects and witnesses said there were several planning sessions for Chandler's abduction. Some even stood on an outdoor hotel balcony and watched Chandler, apparently handcuffed, being led to a car on the night of her death, authorities allege. "In addition to watching out of interest, their job on the balcony was also to act as lookouts," Van Lopik, the state police detective, testified in the affidavit. Once at the house on Chemtron property, Chandler's mouth and eyes were taped shut and her hands bound, according to the affidavit. Paiva, a guard supervisor, lived at the home where a party attended by 15 to 20 people, including about six women, spiraled into torture and murder, the affidavit said. The 23-year-old was repeatedly raped and choked with a belt by numerous guards, the affidavit said. "Laurie Swank has admitted to investigators she was present at the guest house during the incident and that she verbally assaulted Janet as she was being beaten and raped," according to the affidavit. "Laurie admitted that she knew Janet was going to be killed and was present when Janet died." The affidavit identified witnesses who saw Nelson, known as "Bubba," raping and beating Chandler. The other arrested guards -- Paiva, Parker, Williams and Lynch -- are also accused of participating in the beating and raping of Chandler, records show. Lynch was choking Chandler with a belt when she died, according to the affidavit. "Women reported witnessing specific individuals, including Anthony Williams and Robert Lynch, cleaning up Janet before wrapping her up," the document states. 'A sordid affair' State police Lt. John Slenk, supervisor of the collaboration between the state police and Holland police, described the situation among guards at the inn and female staff as "a sordid affair, and it just went bad from top to bottom." "You have dozens of guards in and out of the hotel. There was a lot of alcohol and quite a bit of drugs," he said. "You are going to get a band of renegades, and that's what you got." The Chemtron strike ended two weeks after Chandler's death. Threats against anyone who talked about the murder kept the slaying a mystery for decades as the guards scattered to other states, police say. "I have never investigated a case like this where this many people knew and kept it silent," Slenk said. Paiva, however, disputes all associations that place him at the party or as a part of the crew that allegedly had it in for Chandler. He talked to police the day after and provided a roster of all guards who worked at Chemtron, he said. "If I had known anything, I would have reported it," Paiva said. "I gave them all the information they needed. I did everything I could." Paiva said he and Chandler dated, but the relationship broke off a month before she was killed. He said he had never heard investigators' theory that the Hope student died at the house he lived in. The suspect also said he took and passed DNA and polygraph tests both in the weeks after Chandler was killed and again a few years ago. He suspects Lynch pointed the finger at him. The two didn't get along, Paiva said. "I wasn't part of the crowd," he said.
|