Should parents take the heat for minors' crimes?

Some council members say yes; others skeptical a law would be effective

Friday, September 15, 2006

BY JENNIFER DAVIS
OF THE JOURNAL STAR

PEORIA - Seven years ago it didn't get much support, but perhaps Peoria is now ready to tackle a parental responsibility law.

As at-large Councilman John Morris notes, getting parents to be accountable seemed to be the theme of Wednesday's crime forum - the first in several such planned discussions.

"Absolutely, I would be interested in hearing more and entertaining some parental responsibility ordinance proposals. I think we ought to take a look," he said.

While not all 11 City Council members could be reached Thursday, the majority who were available seem to favor the idea.

At-large Councilman George Jacob said he'd like to find out more about the practical aspects of such an ordinance, but "absolutely I feel parents ought to take responsibility for their children."

Jacob, who has done several ride-alongs with police, recently learned of a 12-year-old car thief.

"When they pulled the car over, there was a 12-year-old driver and 7-year-old passenger. The fundamental question is, if we have 7-year-olds involved in auto theft, where does the responsibility lie? It's not the police's fault; it's not the schools. The question is how do we effectively get at that. We definitely have to start the conversation. The police are telling me (the criminals) are younger, younger, younger. That's a scary thing," Jacob said.

Still, at-large Councilman Chuck Grayeb and 5th District Councilman Patrick Nichting say such an ordinance was proposed in 1999, one of several recommendations from the gang task force they co-chaired years ago.

"We did get feedback from the community that it wasn't necessarily a good idea," Grayeb recalled. "We didn't get too far with that because we brought forth a number of recommendations that were fairly controversial at the time - most of which were implemented. At the time, it was felt it was a feel-good measure."

Even now, Grayeb wonders if it would be effective.

"The question is, how much more are we actually adding to our arsenal of weapons? Right now, under existing rules, we can hammer parents if they are neglecting their children," he said.

Nichting added: "I fully support one. I did then. As times have changed, things have gotten worse."

Second District Councilwoman Barbara Van Auken also is a proponent. "I think that's something we definitely should try."

As for some people's concerns that this will hurt struggling families even more, Van Auken believes the council can be compassionate but firm.

"I trust that we will find appropriate responses. You have to start with notification, some kind of fine, something that puts the parent on notice that the next time around your own consequences could be a lot more serious," said Van Auken.

"Most people in difficult circumstances, they still manage, the vast majority of them, to be very good parents. I don't think we're going to be rounding up hundreds of irresponsible parents."

Mayor Jim Ardis and 3rd District Councilman Bob Manning also lean in favor of such a law, but want more information.

Of those reached, only at-large Councilman Eric Turner was firmly opposed.

Turner, who was raised by a single mother in subsidized housing, knows personally the struggles of the working poor. He fears that fining or jailing struggling parents for the misdeeds of their children will only exacerbate the problem.

"The parents should be held responsible," but not this way, says Turner, a sales executive at Caterpillar Inc. "I have no answers when it comes to that. I wish I did."

Turner does think Peoria could help combat crime by adopting methods that have been successful in other cities, something he's researching for the mayor's task force on crime.

In the meantime, more public forums on crime are being set up.

"I look at this as the beginning of an ongoing dialogue," Ardis said. "I think each (forum) will be uniquely different. There will be a lot more interaction."

Jennifer Davis can be reached at 686-3282 or jdavis@pjstar.com.