-->
        The
          Legel
            Report

11/16 ☼ 4:44 a.m.
MjL
11/16 ☼ 2:53 a.m.
MjL
11/16 ☼ 2:52 a.m.
MjL
11/16 ☼ 2:46 a.m.
MjL
11/16 ☼ 2:45 a.m.
MjL
11/16 ☼ 2:42 a.m.
MjL
11/16 ☼ 2:39 a.m.
MjL
11/15 ✿ 6:56 a.m.
Michael T.
11/15 ✿ 4:51 a.m.
MjL
11/15 ✿ 4:47 a.m.
MjL
11/15 ✿ 3:02 a.m.
MjL
11/15 ✿ 2:58 a.m.
MjL
11/15 ✿ 2:57 a.m.
MjL
11/15 ✿ 2:55 a.m.
MjL
11/15 ✿ 2:53 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:53 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:30 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:29 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:26 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:19 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:15 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:13 a.m.
MjL
11/14 ✡ 2:10 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 8:09 a.m.
Michael T.
11/13 ☯ 7:28 a.m.
Michael T.
11/13 ☯ 5:45 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 4:13 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 3:57 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 3:55 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 3:51 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 3:46 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 3:44 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 3:42 a.m.
MjL
11/13 ☯ 3:37 a.m.
MjL
11/12 ★ 4:32 a.m.
MjL
11/12 ★ 4:25 a.m.
MjL
11/12 ★ 2:25 a.m.
MjL
11/12 ★ 2:08 a.m.
MjL
11/12 ★ 2:07 a.m.
MjL
11/12 ★ 2:02 a.m.
MjL
 

The Legel Report
2006200720082009201020112012201320142015201620172018201920202021202220232024202520262027
Jan Go To January, 2006 
Feb Go To February, 2006 
Mar Go To March, 2006 
April Go To April, 2006 
May Go To May, 2006 
Jun Go To June, 2006 
Jul Go To July, 2006 
Aug Go To August, 2006 
September 2006
Oct Go To October, 2006 
Nov Go To November, 2006 
Dec Go To December, 2006 
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1
2
3
4
 Labor Day 
 Postal Holiday 
 Michael Legel retired 
 on Labor Day, 2003 
5
6
Birthday Jackie Duvall 
7 Full Moon 
8
9
10
11
 Patriot Day 
 U.S. flags are to be 
 flown at half staff. 
12
13
14 Last Quarter Moon 
15
Birthday Dick Duvall 
16
17
18
19
20
Birthday Zachary Lowry 
21
 Autumnal Equinox 
Birthday Rhonda Sommer 
22 New Moon 
23
24
25
26
Birthday Seth Neal 
27
28
29
30 First Quarter Moon 
Last Year There Is No Last Year 
Last Month Go To August, 2006 
 
Next Month Go To October, 2006 
Next Year Go To September, 2007 
Tuesday, September 12 2006




Advice for the Ladies
12 Sep 2006, 5:06 a.m.
The Journal Star printed my Forum submission regarding the naming of the new Cat museum. Of course they had to delete the first paragraph to completely change the tone of the submission. One more strike against free speech in America. If any of it sounds familiar you can see it in yesterday’s blog. Here is the leading paragraph they left out —— just as it appeared yesterday:
Finally the museum “officials” have admitted Caterpillar has bought their new showroom / museum and it would be a “slap to Big Yellow” to give it a name reflecting it’s true origins. Heaven forbid we should treat Caterpillar with the same disdain it has treated Peorians who retired from employment at “Big Yellow”.
Without that paragraph the tone is far less caustic. I guess the editors of the Urinal Jar have a problem with upsetting “Big Yellow”. I sent an email off to Shelley Epstein this morning asking why they removed the first paragraph - we shall see if I get a reply. I will share it with you if I do.

Here is the reply from Christine Smith to the email I wrote asking why the Journal Star had cut the first paragraph from my submission:

Hi, Michael. This is Christine Smith, associate opinion editor. Shelley is at a conference for the remainder of the week. He and I discussed this Monday and, if you’ll notice, letters are always cut for space, which is the primary reason.

Further, your first sentence contains a factual error/misunderstanding of the Word on the Street column: ‘Finally the museum “officials” have admitted Caterpillar has bought their new showroom / museum and it would be a “slap to Big Yellow” to give it a name reflecting it’s true origins.’

[MjL ——> I didn’t have a misunderstanding or factual error, I stated my sarcastic opinion of what I think the truth actually is —— Caterpillar is getting the City of Peoria to build and maintain a show room for them while we all pretend it is a “museum”.]

The Word on the Street column you are referencing says, “But museum officials think letting someone else name the museum for less would be a slap to Big Yellow.”

The column says that museum officials are hesistant
[MjL ——> She doesn’t spell so too good] to sell naming rights to another group for less than $11 million which is what Cat gave. The column did not say that museum officials feel it would be a slap to Big Yellow to give it name reflecting its “true origins,” whatever that means. You failed to elaborate.

Publishing your first sentence, as is, would have skewed the meaning of Jenny Davis’ words.
[MjL ——> I wasn’t skewing her meaning, I was correcting her naive opinion.] We could have killed the letter but opted to run it instead by lobbing [Mjl ——> The correct word is lopping?] off the first paragraph. We certainly did not cut to shield Cat from criticism, and I’d hate for you to think that. [MjL ——> Obvious bullshit]

In the future, just come right out and say what you mean in letters. Being vague or coy rarely works well in writing. I hope this doesn’t discourage you from submitting letters, as the rest of your letter made good points.

Christine Smith
csmith@pjstar.com
Associate Editor
Peoria Journal Star


And here is my reply to Christine:

There was no need to cut for length as it was well under the 250 word restriction —— I counted them. If anyone is hiding behind semantics it is the Journal Star not I —— I said exactly what I meant. Caterpillar is buying their own publicity and calling it a donation to Peoria. Regardless, you misrepresent the writers to the Forum by arbitrarily deciding what they did or did not mean —— or in this case because YOU didn’t understand my point you assume nobody else understands well worded sarcasm.

By stating a “price” on the naming of what is supposedly a public place one can rightfully assume the price setting entity (in this case “Big Yellow") has indeed bought off those naming rights and the “officials” in question wish not to offend the buyer. Obviously the “true origins” of the museum are those who bow to “Big Yellow” in allowing them to determine name and location of what is supposed to be a public museum and is instead an obvious showroom for Caterpillar. If you and the other editors of the Journal Star are this out of touch with the average Peorian’s understanding of how, where and why this museum is being built where it is with Cat funding —— you shouldn’t be editing the words of your Forum submissions. This is a wonderful place for Caterpillar to take their visitors and Cat won’t have to pay a nickel for the upkeep. Another example of a municipality providing for the welfare of a corporation under the guise of public works. If you doubt this, ask a few average people what they REALLY think of this boondoggle. I think you might be surprised.

Michael

I guess I can take some consolation in the fact they had to talk about how to alter my submission in order to make it “politically correct” enough for them to print. Since they place a once in eight weeks limit on their acceptance of editorials, I will have to wait another two months or so before I can test their editing abilities again. Isn’t “free speech” a wonderful thing!

From Christine at the Journal Star

Michael, I’m sorry you feel that the we misrepresent writers to the Forum. I strongly disagree. We provide a valuable service to the community by publishing their letters, and publication is a privilege, not a right. No decision is “arbitrary.” [MjL ——> She doesn’t understand that a decision to change my words without consulting me is “arbitrary” (Unrestrained and autocratic in the use of authority). Just because SHE considered the decision to change it doesn’t mean it was proper to do so without my consultation.]

I coach Forum writers like yourself every day, asking them clarify what they meant or, when appropriate, advising them to cut or add to their letters. We do not decide what our Forum writers mean, nor do we alter their opinions.

Just because a letter is less than 250 words does not mean that it will run in its entirety. And again, your sentence —— “Finally the museum ‘officials’ have admitted Caterpillar has bought their new showroom / museum and it would be a ‘slap to Big Yellow’ to give it a name reflecting it’s true origins” —— simply does not make a lick of sense. You’re saying that museum officials feel it would be a slap to Caterpillar to give the museum a name reflecting the museum’s true origins. OK, WHAT are the museum’s “true origins”? What are you talking about? What does that have to do with the $11 million naming rights and the sentence in Jenny Davis’ column? It’s not well-worded sarcasm, it’s a complete non sequitor.

The sentence also contains a grammatical error: “it’s” should be “its.”

Why didn’t you just say what you said in your email: “Caterpillar is buying their own publicity and calling it a donation to Peoria”? That’s perfectly clear and would have been much better. I certainly would have printed that, except of course Caterpillar is not a plural noun and it takes “its” as a singular possessive, not “their.”


From MjL to Christine at the Journal Star:

From the tone of your reply it is obvious you shouldn’t “coach” anyone on how to be sarcastic. (That’s sarcasm!) And you indeed alter the tone and intent of a submission by totally removing the first paragraph. I don’t understand how you see any ambiguity in the words “Caterpillar has bought their new showroom / museum”. And that was not the only sentence omitted. Finally, attacking grammatical errors is the last resort of a failed argument. It does nothing to address the obvious point that the tone and intent of what I wrote was altered.

I believe you should either print the submission as written, warts and all, or don’t print it all. Editing the content alters the words of the person named at the end of the submission. I did not write ONLY what was printed above my name —— the removal of the first paragraph altered substantially what I did write and it is wrong to leave people with a misrepresentation of what I DID write. Do you not see that omission is indeed an arbitrary alteration with you or other editors as arbiters? Any change from the original is an arbitrary change. ANY change to a Forum submission is a misrepresentation of the author’s submission. That is a fact, not a feeling. I also understand the difference between rights and privileges. I also understand the difference between conveying a message and altering it - by omission, alteration or addition.

I suspect we could lecture each other all day every day and still come to no better conclusions. I will concede my grammatical errors and surrender to your obvious right to print what you wish in your paper. Please, in the future, if you can’t publish what is submitted in its (got that one right!) entirety, don’t publish it at all without first discussing the alterations with the author. Otherwise put YOUR name at the bottom of what you DO publish.

Michael

PS No offense taken or intended —— it is after all a rather mundane topic unworthy of rancor. I just love to debate (argue) these things and will endeavor to be more clear and concise in the future.

Have a great day!

From Christine at the Journal Star:

Agreed. If you decide to write another letter in the future, I will either call you if I have questions or spike it.

Well, she went from not wanting to discourage me from writing, to correcting my grammar and good sense, to “if you decide to write another letter in the future”. Dare I suspect anything I submit in the future will get “spiked”? It is obvious that Christine still does not understand her role as editor is not to question (If I have any questions?) an editorial opinion or to edit it. It should either be printed or not. Period. She and the other editors of the Journal Star, as with many publications today, believe it is their duty to screen and edit public opinion rather than simply convey that opinion as submitted in its original form. After all that dialogue I think it is fair to say I did not alter her opinion of what her editorial duties should be. She acts more like a school teacher than an opinion page editor. And I am quite sure her aloof attitude is part and parcel of the whole “privilege” line of thought. She is the gatekeeper of what is properly submitted for publication and she has no qualms about altering the submission and leaving the author’s name on it as if it were the original. There ought to be a word for such journalistic sins of omission. If it is plagiarism to put your name to the words of someone else, what do you call putting a person’s name to words they didn’t write or only SOME of the words they did write.
MjL 12 Sep 2006, 6:00 a.m.

Comment Guidelines     Hashtags     Help

*Name:
Email:
Notify me about new comments on this page
Hide my email
*Text: