An unclear message the same as none at all

Doug Finke
Statehouse Insider

Sunday, October 8, 2006

After listening to last Monday's debate between Gov. Rod Blagojevich and Treasurer Judy Baar Topinka, there's only one conclusion to draw: Blagojevich should schedule a lot more debates.

It's not that Blagojevich rose to the occasion; he didn't. It was that Topinka was so unfocused, she managed to do the near-impossible. She made Blagojevich look gubernatorial.

Throughout the debate, Topinka seldom stayed on one thought long enough to finish before launching into something else. If you follow state government news very closely, you might have been able to figure out what she was getting at, but even we had trouble keeping up at times.

Case in point: the controversy over the property tax assessment on Blagojevich's Chicago house. The story had only recently broken in two Chicago-area newspapers and hadn't yet made its way into the downstate media.

Yet Topinka launched into the topic as though the story and its complicated details were common knowledge to the radio debate's listeners. She went on about how Blagojevich is taxed at 1 percent while everyone else is taxed at 30 percent, something confusing to any property owner who knows that neither figure is true. In fact, the controversy had to do with the assessed value of Blagojevich's house going up 1 percent while his neighbors got hit with 30 percent hikes. But good luck figuring that out from what Topinka said.

It's not like Topinka couldn't have punched holes in Blagojevich's spiel. The governor always works from a script, including at the debate. Topinka had to know what he would talk about. Universal preschool. All Kids health care. His plan to boost education funding by selling the lottery.

Each of those programs could have been attacked. There isn't enough money in the budget to make universal preschool truly universal, so it remains a slogan rather than a program. Many doctors won't accept All Kids because the state is so far behind in paying its bills. After four years, the bottom drops out of Blagojevich's education funding plan and even the administration isn't sure how it will replace the money.

Topinka whiffed on the first two issues and sort of hit on the education issue. But again, if you didn't already know about the shortcomings of the education plan, you may not have understood what Topinka was saying.

It comes down to this: If you can't communicate a message, you might as well not have one.

Electrifying concept

House Speaker Michael Madigan, D-Chicago, wants Blagojevich to immediately call a special session of the General Assembly so lawmakers can freeze electric rates, which otherwise are set to skyrocket in January. Blagojevich said he would, but with a huge loophole. He'll do it only if he's convinced the votes are there to pass a freeze.

All the governor has to do is keep saying he doesn't think the votes are there and he can avoid a potentially nasty showdown with his ally, Senate President Emil Jones, D-Chicago, who isn't keen on the rate freeze idea. In the meantime, Blagojevich and Madigan can both cluck about what a terrible thing the rate hikes are and pretend they are doing something without really doing anything.

Not like that's never happened before in the Statehouse.

Misleading ads

Of all the stuff flying in the gubernatorial campaign, this isn't the biggest issue, but it is really annoying.

Blagojevich has been airing various TV ads saying that Topinka was ex-Gov. George Ryan's treasurer when Ryan was running up an enormous state debt. As Ryan's treasurer, the ads maintain, Topinka should have done something to stop it.

Of course, the ads don't mention that the treasurer is an independently elected state official whose primary job is to invest state funds until they are needed to pay bills. Instead, people are left with the impression that Topinka was a Ryan employee who looked the other way rather than blow the whistle on her boss. It's misleading.

If Blagojevich is going to continue making this assertion, let's take his logic a step further. If Topinka was Ryan's treasurer, then she is also Blagojevich's treasurer. She's been that for the past four years while the administration has solved (it claims) the state deficit. If she deserves blame for the huge state deficit, then she deserves credit for eliminating that deficit.

Doug Finke is a columnist and statehouse reporter for Copley News Service. He can be reached at (217) 788-1527 or by e-mail at doug.finke@sj-r.com.