Parents see high cost to fundraisers

Many worn down by frequent sales, repetitive themes

Tuesday, October 17, 2006

PEORIA - Jill Woolley's children are young, but they've already worn her out with school fundraisers.

The Pekin mother's two children, Austin and Abbi, are in kindergarten and second grade respectively at Willow Primary School, where they recently began a fund drive selling gift wrap, candy and cooking utensils.

Willow Primary discourages children from going door to door, so the weight falls mostly on her to contact family and friends, Woolley said.

"It puts pressure on the parents," she said, noting that Abbi came home excited about selling the products and helping the school.

Woolley, envisioning years of similar fundraisers ahead, said she appreciates the need to raise money, but selling candy and wrapping paper may not be the best way to go about it.

"I would say go back to the old-fashioned fundraisers," where people give direct donations, she said.

Woolley is hardly alone. For parents, dealing with school fundraisers has become a rite of passage, as schools or parent-teacher organizations seek to fill budget gaps by using students as salespeople.

For many, the money-raising tool has become tiring, as children sell similar products year after year, so much so that the industry has begun to see revenue drop in the past few years.

Jon Krueger, a spokesperson for the Association of Fund-Raising Distributors and Suppliers, said revenue has decreased 11 percent in the past four years. Nationally, fundraisers bring in around $1.7 billion annually for schools.

"Unfortunately, fundraising has become something of a saturated market," Krueger said. "When fewer people participate, that sometimes results in more fundraisers, but that's not the way to solve the problem."

Discount cards, candy bars, cookie dough, magazines and flower bulbs are just a few of the offerings of today's school fundraisers. Children are sent home with a packet or catalog for the fundraiser and often given prep talks on how to sell. Motivated by prizes and the need to help out their schools, relatives and family friends are quickly targeted for sales, and parents solicit their colleagues at the workplace.

Kylee Durst, a fifth-grader from Washburn, recently finished a fundraiser where she sold 25 items, making her one of the top sellers in her class. Much of her motivation, she said, came from the various incentives the school offered to its best sellers, most notably a quick trip in the "cash machine," an inflated container that students stand in as they try to grab money that is blown around them.

Other than the cash machine, Kylee rattled of a list of cheap, easily breakable trinkets she won last year, including Mr. Bacon, a small toy pig that waddles and oinks.

"That's one of the ones that didn't work," she said with a grin.

While Kylee is anxiously awaiting her turn in the cash machine this year, her mother, Sheila Durst, seemed a bit relieved that the fund drive was over.

"Honestly, I wasn't going to let her sell at first," Durst said. "It's a lot - when you've got every kid in the sixth grade selling the same thing, that's hard."

Durst also has a son in the high school who was selling discount cards.

"At the same time the whole high school was selling that, the whole elementary school was selling gift wrap," she said with a slight look of exasperation.

Across the nation, schools have increasingly strained budgets, in part because of rising health-care costs, salaries and increased federal regulation, said Tim Sullivan, president of "PTO Today" magazine.

"More than ever, parent groups are counted on for providing things at school that were once part of the school budget," he said.

Sullivan gave the example of playgrounds, which used to be built with district funds at new schools. Today, he said, the vast majority come from outside funding, such as parent groups.

Sullivan acknowledged that the rising number of fundraisers may be taxing on families, and said that the solution is more effective, large fundraisers, as opposed to the constant stream of smaller fund drives that occur in some school districts.

"These really good-intentioned groups, when they feel this pressure, they sometimes fund raise too much instead of fundraising better," he said.

Some area schools allow only one fundraiser per year, which limits the fatigue on parents. At Pekin's Willow Elementary, Principal Lisa VanNatta said she expects around $8,000 to $10,000 to come in from the sale.

"This is just a way to help us - a way to get us some of the things we want and need," VanNatta said.

Eliot Brown can be reached at 686-3114 or ebrown@pjstar.com.