Car wreck with cop an unlucky situation

Phil Luciano
NEWS COLUMNIST

Wednesday, November 8, 2006

Garrett Shearburn thinks state law cheated him out of a car.

His car got totaled in a wreck with a city of Peoria squad car. But because of an intriguing state law, Shearburn has no way of even trying to get the city to reimburse him,

"I think it's kind of weird," he says.

At 11:10 p.m. on July 2, Shearburn, 27, of Peoria was pulling off westbound Interstate 74 at the University Street exit. At the top of the ramp is a traffic light. As Shearburn neared the light, it was red. So he stopped.

Meantime, a city cop was northbound on University Street, responding to a domestic call. According to a police report, the officer had his lights and siren on as he approached the I-74 overpass.

The report states the officer "thought the intersection was clear." So did Shearburn. As the ramp light turned green, he neither heard the siren nor saw the squad car.

So, he started to pull from the ramp and turn left to go south on University Street. But as soon as he entered the intersection, the cop car clipped the rear of his auto, sending Shearburn spinning like a top.

Luckily, neither driver was hurt badly. The cop had a sore knee and thigh, but that was it.

The cars weren't so lucky. Both sustained severe damage.

The state traffic code on emergency vehicles holds that other motorists must get out of the way. Still, the laws also direct drivers of emergency vehicles to "drive with due regard for the safety of all persons using the highway."

The police report lists a "contributing cause" of the wreck as Shearburn's "failure to yield right of way." However, Shearburn was not issued a ticket, nor was the cop.

The city asked Shearburn's insurer to pay $9,550 to fix the squad car. Citing the lack of a ticket against Shearburn, the insurer said no.

Meanwhile, Shearburn had only liability insurance for his car, a '95 Pontiac Grand Prix. So he asked the city to reimburse him its value: $2,000.

I can't tell if Shearburn is justified. By law, he is supposed to get out of the way of cop cars. Still, I've been in his shoes, driving along responsibly when an ambulance, squad car or fire truck seemingly came out of nowhere.

But Shearburn won't get the chance to make his case. The city turned him down flat. And that's what the law allows.

A letter to Shearburn from the city's legal staff explained the crux of the Local Government and Governmental Tort Immunity Act: "Neither local public entity, nor a public employee acting within the scope of his employment, is liable for an injury caused by the negligent operation of a motor vehicle or firefighting or rescue equipment, when responding to an emergency call."

So, even if the cop were negligent, the law tells Shearburn he's out of luck.

In part, I understand the idea behind the law. We want emergency vehicles to move fast. We don't want the drivers to be slow-footed for fear of liability.

Still, as mentioned before, the vehicle code mandates that emergency-vehicle drivers use "due caution." It seems unfair that civil law doesn't allow the same consideration to allow for potential insurance claims.

Anyway, Shearburn now has another car. And he's upgraded his auto insurance to include comprehensive coverage.

"The next time I get hit by a cop, I'll be ready," he says.

PHIL LUCIANO is a columnist with the Journal Star. He can be reached at pluciano@pjstar.com, 686-3155 or (800) 225-5757, Ext. 3155.