Opinion

Habeas corpus? Posse Comitatus? Nada
By Bill Knight
Friday, November 10, 2006 9:08 AM CST
Times columnist
Blame fast food and dumb TV, the bread and circuses of the age.
Blame spineless Democrats who surrendered to the Bush administration and relinquished the role of opposition.
Blame those Republicans who gave in to the temptation of power and betrayed their party, true conservatism and the tenets of the faith Rightwing extremists try to exploit.
Blame it on Cain - it doesn't matter who you blame - because the United States is a different place than it was a year ago, and part of that is due to two laws President Bush signed on October 17: the Military Commission Act of 2006 and the Defense Authorization Act of 2007.
In the name of fighting terrorism, the first eliminates a pillar of democracy, habeas corpus, and the second eliminates states' right to control their militia and protect citizens from a military takeover - another bulwark of liberty, Posse Comitatus.
Habeas corpus (Latin for “you have the body”) is a way prisoners can seek release from unlawful detention.
A writ of habeas corpus is an order ordering an official to bring a detainee to court so it can be determined whether or not that person is imprisoned lawfully or should be released.
It guards peoples in many countries from arbitrary state action. Uh, it used to.
Posse Comitatus (Latin for “county force”) has been a federal law for more than half the nation's existence. It prohibits federal military personnel from acting in a law enforcement capacity within the United States, unless authorized by the Constitution or Congress.
Posse Comitatus limits the powers of the federal government to declare martial law. That is, it used to.
It's a disservice to Republicans to make it solely their responsibility. Great Republicans such as Illinois' Chuck Percy and Paul Findlay, 1960s statesmen like George Romney and William Scranton, and independent-minded figures like Paul McCloskey and Margaret Chase Smith would not recognize what the extreme Right has done to the GOP.
Looking across the aisle, one reels at the thought of what venomous voices like Rush Limbaugh, Ann Coulter and Bill O'Reilly would scream if posse comitatus and habeas corpus were killed by Democrats, such as progressive Dennis Kucinich or the divisive Al Sharpton, much less the moderate Bill Clinton.
A handful of people have sounded an alarm, even if the fire has been started.
Commenting on the Defense Authorization Act, Republican Senator Kit Bond of Missouri said, “I share our governors' concern and opposition. This would give our nation's governors less control over their Guard units and provide the President with unnecessary and unprecedented power to invoke martial law.”
Bond's Senate colleague, Democrat Patrick Leahy of Vermont, said “The language needlessly makes it easier for a President to declare martial law. (It) will allow the President to use the military, including the National Guard, to carry out law enforcement activities without the consent of a governor.”
Commenting on the Military Commission Act, Yale law professor Bruce Ackerman said, “If Congress can strip courts of jurisdiction over cases because it fears their outcome, judicial independence is threatened.”
With a stroke of a pen, Bush now can avoid courts - even the Republican-controlled U.S. Supreme Court, which has repeatedly ordered detainees tried or freed - and declare anyone an “unlawful enemy combatant” and jail them indefinitely. Anyone.
With a stroke of a pen, Bush now can now use the Defense Authorization Act and - in the law's words, “employ the armed forces, including the National Guard in Federal service, to restore public order and enforce the laws of the United States when, as a result of a natural disaster, epidemic, or other serious public health emergency, terrorist attack or incident, or other condition in any State or possession of the United States, the President determines that domestic violence has occurred to such an extent that the constituted authorities of the State or possession are incapable of maintaining public order, in order to suppress, in any State, any insurrection, domestic violence, unlawful combination, or conspiracy.”
Frank Morales, an Episcopal priest from New York, writes that roundups of protestors are possible, and - without habeas corpus - they can be imprisoned indefinitely in detention camps he says are being built by Halliburton.
“The implications of changing the Act are enormous, but this change was just slipped in the defense bill as a rider with little study,” Leahy adds. “I have wondered how Congress could have gotten to this point. I can only surmise that we arrived at this outcome because we are too unwilling to carry out our responsibilities to raise and support an Army.”
Illinois' Congressional delegation had some opposition to the Military Commission Act, as 9 of 10 Democratic Congressmen voted against it (Melissa Bean joined Ray LaHood and other Republicans supporting the measure); it passed the House 253-168, with 12 not voting. But joining LaHood in the 396-31 passage of the annual Defense Authorization Act were Democratic Congressman Bean, Costello, Davis, Emanuel, Gutierrez, Lipinski, Jackson and Rush. (Lane Evans did not vote.)
“Because of this rubberstamp Congress,” Leahy said, “we fail our Constitution, we make it easier for the President to declare martial law and trample on local and state sovereignty.”
Americans of good will must demand that Congress acts as a check on the executive branch, and stand behind a judiciary that must balance any overreaching administration.
The fire must be extinguished before the Constitution is consumed and with it, our nation.
Bill Knight is an award-winning journalist who teaches at Western Illinois University. Contact him at bill.knight@hotmail.com.
The opinions expressed in this column are not necessarily those of the Pekin Daily Times.
|