![]() Sirens no guarantee of getting noticed
NEWS COLUMNIST
Tuesday, November 14, 2006 I thought I'd be pounded by cops.A column last week discussed legal quirks of a wreck between a Peoria squad car and a civilian auto. The latter pulled into what the driver thought was a clear intersection. He says he neither heard nor saw the squad car that blasted into his car. I acknowledged I had no idea who was at fault. In fact, no tickets were issued to either driver. But I did say I'd been in that driver's shoes. Repeatedly, while driving around Peoria in a seemingly alert state of mind, I'd been shocked to suddenly spot a speeding emergency-vehicle almost on top of me. I figured that observation might prompt some poison-pen letters from area men and women in blue. After all, they're at risk when rushing to calls, and motorists are supposed to get out of their way. Instead, I got no such complaints. I figured out why, after I received a thoughtful e-mail from Farmington Police Chief Jim Arrington. Arrington, who has been in law enforcement for 27 years, says he wishes cars got out of the way of emergency vehicles more quickly and consistently. But he has come to the conclusion that drivers - even the good ones - simply don't pick up on sirens and lights. "It's just the way it is," he says. After I talked to him, I did a little research. Indeed, emergency responders nationally are constantly trying to figure out ways to make their vehicles more conspicuous. I found an alarming fact from the U.S. Fire Administration, a branch of the Department of Homeland Security. In 30 percent of crashes involving emergency vehicles and civilian vehicles, the latter noticed no sirens or lights before impact. Chief Arrington says sirens don't work well. Autos' air fans and radios make noise, and today's cars are well soundproofed. As such, many motorists don't pick up the blare of a siren. "I think it dissipates," Arrington says. "I'm not an engineer. But I don't think it carries very well." The U.S. Department of Transportation agrees. Studies showed sirens don't become sufficiently noticeable until an emergency vehicle gets 8 to 12 meters (26 to 40 feet) from an urban intersection. So, the department has concluded sirens alone will never be an effective warning device. Still, visual cues account for 90 percent of drivers' sensory intake. So emergency vehicles' lights and colors are the most important attention-getters. Chief Arrington says most emergency responders have gone to bright-white headlights that flash in patterns. That's the most visible sight level, he says - rather than the old-style rooftop lights. Plus, the not-for-profit National Academies of Emergency Dispatch says white is the most noticeable light, followed by green, amber and red. But white alone can fail to identify the vehicle as an emergency responder. Often, other colors are mixed in. But green can suggest "go" or "safe." Yellow often looks too close to white, and therefore adds little to the message. Red comes off as weak and sometimes gets misidentified as a tail lamp. Blue doesn't seem to stand out much, either. Meanwhile, some departments have increased the power or strobe their lights. But that sometimes masks civilian cars' brakes and tail lights - thus possibly increasing the chance of a rear-ending, according go the Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute. As for the vehicles themselves, the most visible color is lime-yellow. You don't see that hue too often. Percentage-wise, lime-yellow fire trucks account for fewer than half the wrecks traditional red fire trucks do, according to Firehouse magazine. All of these factors make for tough vehicle decisions for police, firefighter and ambulance services. But Chief Arrington says emergency workers understand that no setup is perfect. "I believe that most police officers do not think these drivers are doing anything wrong," he says. "They just are not paying attention." Mind you, he's not saying we're careless. In fact, he admits that when in his personal car he has been shocked to find an emergency vehicle seemingly pop out of nowhere. "When we're driving, we're bored," he says. "I don't think most of us are like we were in driver's ed: Always alert." He says emergency agencies can keep looking for better light and siren technology. In the end, though, he argues for caution - by civilians as well as emergency responders. "Every time I turn those lights and siren on, I know I'm going to have difficultly with someone seeing me," he says. "You've got to be very defensive." PHIL LUCIANO is a columnist with the Journal Star. He can be reached at pluciano@pjstar.com, 686-3155 or (800) 225-5757, Ext. 3155. |