![]() Wage hike raises questionsSupporters, opponents see different results of $1 increase in minimum wageSunday, November 26, 2006 SPRINGFIELD - Raising Illinois' minimum wage by $1 would put a little more money in the pockets of hardworking people just scraping by as they help support families. Children would get healthier breakfasts. Workers would be able to ride the bus instead of walking.At least, that's the picture painted by supporters of the increase. Opponents offer a different view: The increase would mostly benefit teenagers and other workers who don't rely on their minimum-wage jobs to feed relatives or pay the rent. Meanwhile, those who truly need their jobs might be laid off as businesses cut back to pay the higher wages. There are no simple answers for Illinois lawmakers pondering legislation that would raise the minimum wage to $7.50 an hour, up from $6.50, and allow it to rise automatically each year to keep pace with inflation. Although the federal minimum remains far lower, at $5.15, businesses operating in Illinois would have to pay the higher amount. Someone working 40 hours a week at the higher minimum would earn $15,600 a year instead of $13,520. As legislation to increase the minimum wage awaits action in the House - it was approved by the state Senate already - both sides point to studies supporting their position and offer anecdotes to drive home an increase's real-world impact. Proponents point to people like Muriel Jones of Chicago, who works 50 hours a week caring for people with cancer, Alzheimer's, arthritis and other illnesses. She bathes them, cleans their homes, helps with their medications. She already makes $7.55 an hour, but hopes increasing the minimum would have a ripple effect that bumps up her pay, too - maybe by 10 cents. "It's not much, but it's better than nothing," said Jones, who described raising two children on low-wage jobs, choosing between eating lunch and buying a bus ticket, praying she didn't get sick. The state has no official statistics on how many people earn the minimum wage in Illinois. Gov. Rod Blagojevich's administration cites estimates from increase proponents, who say 308,000 Illinoisans make between $6.50 and $7.50 an hour. They estimate an additional 339,000 people making a little more than $7.50 probably would get raises, too. But experts disagree on who these people are. The pro-increase Economic Policy Institute says 81 percent are 20 or older, more than half work full time and one-fifth are parents - in other words, not just teenagers earning a little pocket money. Opponents present the opposite message. One group that looked at the possibility of raising the federal minimum wage to $7.25 said it found that those who would benefit have an average family income of $55,735 a year. Fewer than one in five minimum-wage employees are the sole breadwinners for their family, according to the Employment Policies Institute. Opponents also argue that raising the minimum wage forces businesses to cut jobs and ends up hurting the poorest workers and weakening the economy in general. Illinois has raised the minimum wage before. In January 2004, it jumped from the federal level to a new state minimum of $5.50. A year later, it rose to $6.50. If those increases hampered the economy, the impact is not obvious from looking at federal employment statistics. Since December 2003, the number of people working in Illinois has grown by 6.4 percent. The unemployment rate dropped from 6.6 percent to 4.4 percent. That's a significantly better record than the Midwest as a whole, which saw employment grow by 3.6 percent. The Midwest unemployment rate fell from 5.8 percent to 4.8 percent. Even Illinois' border areas, which compete against businesses in states with lower minimum wages, don't show signs of an economic slowdown. Employment grew 7.5 percent in the Danville area, while neighboring Indiana's overall growth was only 3.7 percent. The Rockford area has enjoyed 8.4 percent employment growth, compared to 2.4 percent in Wisconsin. Even so, business owners said they feel the pinch. Mike Leifheit, owner of the Irish Rose Saloon in Rockford, said the last minimum wage increase cost him $20,000 for the year - more than the pub's profit. "It's like a kick in the butt to us," he said. If the minimum goes up again, he'd have to find more money to pay employees and the higher taxes and unemployment insurance costs that go along with it. "It's a heavy expenditure. It's four times my insurance. It's more than it costs me to heat and electrify my building," Leifheit said. Leifheit strongly objects to raising the minimum for waiters and others who make tips. They can be paid $3.90, or 60 percent of the minimum wage, under current law. With the increase, they'll make $4.50. Leifheit argued that, between wages and tips, his wait staff makes good money. The ones who need a raise are the kitchen staff, who already make more than minimum and wouldn't be affected by the increase, he said. It's possible that objection could be addressed before lawmakers take final action on the proposed increase. The Senate voted 33-21 for the increase. Now it goes to the Illinois House, where Speaker Michael Madigan has shown little interest in deciding the question during the Legislature's fall session. If the issue is postponed until next year, or if changes are needed to build support immediately, the measure could be overhauled to exclude waiters or eliminate the annual cost-of-living increase. But supporters hope to pass it now, saying it's a question of fundamental fairness. "It is indeed a moral issue. How can we truly expect that anyone in the state of Illinois can survive and live a decent life on $13,520?" Illinois AFL-CIO President Margaret Blackshere told state senators. "It is, in my opinion, obscene and immoral."
|