Electric rate freeze fails in House

Lawmakers could vote again in January; Jones
Cross unveil plan that would increase costs gradually

Wednesday, November 29, 2006

SPRINGFIELD - A proposal to extend an existing electric rate freeze for three more years failed to win approval in the Illinois House Tuesday, but lawmakers could get another chance to vote on the idea in January.

The legislation, pushed by Democratic Rep. George Scully of Flossmoor, was written in an effort to head off anticipated electric rate increases for customers of Ameren and Commonwealth Edison. The new rates are to take effect with the new year and could be as much as 55 percent for the average customer.

Also Tuesday, Senate President Emil Jones and House Republican Leader Tom Cross unveiled the framework of what they called a compromise plan to increase electricity rates gradually over a three-year period.

Cross, R-Oswego, said the plan would cap rate hikes while ensuring a reliable power supply for Illinois.

"We believe this is a reasonable compromise," said Jones, D-Chicago, who added that the legislation still has some "kinks" to be worked out.

The rate increases are a result of the state's 1997 electric deregulation law, which included the rate freeze. Lawmakers who supported that measure believed competition would develop among electric companies, enabling customers to shop for electricity in the same way they shop for other items. That scenario has not developed.

Under the Jones-Cross plan, Ameren customers would see a 14 percent rate increase in each of the next three years. Those increases would be based on the 2006 average rate, Jones said.

Sen. James Clayborne, the

Senate Democrats' point man on utility issues, said later that the specifics would differ in each of the three Ameren service territories and that those details are in the works.

ComEd customers would see smaller increases: 7 percent in each of the first two years and 8 percent in the third year.

An Ameren spokesman said he did not know enough about the new proposal to comment on it.

Meanwhile, Scully's plan to extend the rate freeze needed a supermajority of 71 House votes to advance to the Senate, but it fell short by fewer than 10 votes. The legislation is Senate Bill 1714.

Steve Brown, spokesman for House Speaker Michael Madigan, D-Chicago, said the bill could come up for a vote again in January, when different rules will be in effect. At that point, it would need a simple majority of just 60 "yes" votes.

He said the bill attracted 66 affirmative votes Tuesday.

"We plan to persist," Brown said, adding that Madigan prefers a continued rate freeze to a phase-in plan.

No official roll call on Tuesday's vote exists because Scully made a parliamentary move that would enable the bill to come up for a second vote.

Even so, among local lawmakers, Reps. Aaron Schock, R-Peoria, Mike Smith, D-Canton, Keith Sommer, R-Morton, Donald Moffitt, R-Gilson, and Frank Mautino, D-Spring Valley, voted "yes." Rep. David Leitch, R-Peoria, voted "no."

During debate, opponents of the legislation suggested it was a political ploy and would trigger problems with the utility companies and with the electricity supply in Illinois. California experienced such problems a few years ago, some of them said.

"We are taking ourselves today down a road that California traveled," said Rep. Bill Black, R-Danville. "Why don't we learn from others' mistakes?"

But supporters of a continued freeze said consumers deserve a break. They also said they don't believe the utility companies' statements that a longer rate freeze could push them to financial ruin.

Adriana Colindres can be reached at (217) 782-6292 or adriana.colindres@sj-r.com.