
|
12/03/2006 Big Brother Protecting Us?This Curmudgeon is a little more difficult to dissect and articulate. Obviously we expect our elected governments to legislate laws to protect us and to make it possible to protect ourselves. A recent law requiring citizens to have carbon monoxide detectors illustrates this situation.I don’t quibble with concern for people who die from carbon monoxide poisoning. But requiring consumers to make sure their appliances are safe? Why not require the manufacturer of these devices install the detector on their product? Why isn’t the manufacturer held more responsible for the safety of their product? Why hold the consumer liable for this? And then at some point I have to ask myself —— if the detectors are ready available for anyone to buy them —— why not simply let the people decide for themselves? Do we really want Big Brother forcing us to live the way some bureaucrat thinks we should? Should Big Brother decide people who live in high crime areas should have to buy and wear bullet-proof vests? Make you wear your gloves when it is cold outside? When are we going to draw the line on where we go with these protections and when do we decide to start protecting our citizens instead of the business which shouldn’t sell furnaces or stoves that kill people. And I understand that many times it is the faulty maintenance or installation of these devices and many times the simple ignorance of a victim who misuses them. But shouldn’t the business shoulder some responsibility for insuring they provide a safe product? I appreciate Big Brother’s concern for me but often I get the feeling Big Brother is more concerned about helping its business Masters avoid law suits. I believe if Big Brother were really concerned about citizens safety it would make laws that would really protect people rather than this silly Band-Aid approach which says if the victim doesn’t die from not having the detector we will throw the victim in jail. Sorta like blaming the rape victim for not wearing a chastity belt? |