Promises, plans don’t plow snow in ‘99 or ‘06

[Link is Broken] http://www.pjstar.com/stories/120706/PHI_BBO320SP.033.shtml

Phil Luciano
NEWS COLUMNIST
Thursday, December 7, 2006
The Peoria City Council got steamed about snow.

They raised voices.  They stomped their feet.  They pointed fingers.
 
And in the end, they made a solemn promise to Peoria: Never again would snow paralyze the city and outrage residents.  The council vowed to do better.
 
In 1999.
 
That’s what makes the current council’s self-questioning so curious.  They city has been through this before - just seven years ago.
 
Tell me if any of the following sounds familiar, from the aftermath of 1999’s Storm to End All Storms:
 
- Days after 13 inches hit, a West Bluff resident shoveled out the driveway but couldn’t go anywhere.  The city still hadn’t plowed his street.  “Isn’t this a mess?” he said, frustrated.
 
- One reader complained to the Journal Star, “The heavy snow had stopped by Saturday night, and as I make this call on Tuesday morning, my street has not been plowed.”
 
- Residents citywide were equally as cranky.  Council members got pounded by calls and voice mails.  One got 300.
 
- Peorians carped about plows not touching their alleys, which in older neighbors allow the only access to garages.
 
- “My patience is worn pretty thin over this entire episode,” said then-at-large Councilwoman Camille Gibson.  “Just because we haven’t had this problem since 1979 doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be prepared for another one.”
 
- Said at-large Councilman Gary Sandberg said, “The staff worked hard, but they didn’t work smart.”
 
- Added at-large Councilman Eric Turner, “All I can say is, maybe we can get the committee to make a plan.  It’s just a possibility, but we’ve got to do something.”
 
So the council, after chewing each other’s heads off - and ripping apart then-City Manager Mike McKnight and his staff - formed a committee and created Snow Plan 2000.
 
They talked a good game:
 
- Plows, rather than clearing curb to curb, would make “in” and “out” lanes on residential streets.  That way, drivers would have basic access citywide.
 
- The city would clear sidewalks in Downtown business districts and along busy streets.
 
- All alleys, which provided crucial garage access in older neighborhoods, would be cleared, even if that meant hiring private contractors.
 
Did the plan work?  You tell me.
 
Look, I realize we live in the Midwest.  Once in a while, we have to endure Mother Nature’s white whimsey.
 
But at its meeting Tuesday, the council sounded as if it had never before considered snow removal.
 
“We got beat this weekend,” 3rd District Councilman Bob Manning said.  “I just want to know, was it a close game or a good, old-fashioned thumping?”
 
Manning wasn’t on the council in ‘99, but he’s lived in Peoria all his life.  John Morris wasn’t on the council when the storm hit just after New Year’s Day 1999 but was elected to an at-large seat that spring.
 
Morris said Tuesday, “Either we had a snow plan that failed, or we failed to implement the snow plan.”
 
To answer his question, maybe the council should dust off Snow Plan 2000 and see how the city scored.  I don’t know if the fault lies in the plan or the execution.
 
But I do know this: When we get the next big snow in 2013, I hope council members aren’t confused and screaming again.
 
PHIL LUCIANO is a columnist with the Journal Star.  He can be reached at pluciano@pjstar.com, 686-3155 or (800) 225-5757, Ext.  3155.