Duty falls to county to right tax mess

[Link is Broken] http://www.pjstar.com/stories/121006/TER_BBP1VSEI.037.shtml

Terry Bibo
NEWS COLUMNIST
Sunday, December 10, 2006
 
Through no fault of their own, Joe Vanderheydt and his neighbors found themselves in one of the most bizarre tax screw-ups Tazewell County ever has seen.

As a result, although Joe had been paying his property taxes for more than a decade, he nearly lost his Groveland home to a tax scavenger because his tax checks had been applied to his neighbors’ taxes, and his neighbors’ tax checks were going to pay for the doghouse on an otherwise empty lot.
 
“Thank God we’re all friends,” says Ron Haven.
 
And they remain friends, even though it took a year, a private attorney, and up to $10,000 to correct the county’s mistakes. Now the Vanderheydts, the Havens, and another family on the corner would like the county to pay for the mess it created. Not for their time or lost sleep or lost work. Just for their out-of-pocket costs.
 
The county might, or it might not.
 
“There’s no law that says they’ve got to pay us,” Ron Haven says.
 
The Groveland neighbors first learned about this mess in late September of 2005. Groveland Missionary Church had purchased the property next to Joe Vanderheydt’s house. For several years, it had belonged to his brother, John, and the two had shared a garage that straddled the property line. Logically enough, the church wondered who owned the garage. But when the county assessor’s office went out to check, it found that the block didn’t match the property record. It “corrected” its mistake and sent letters to the property owners.
 
“I think this means we don’t own the land our house sits on,” Ron told his wife, Vickie, who compared notes with Joe’s wife, Tracy, on their regular morning walk.
 
Joe called the county clerk’s office that same day. “The problem’s bigger than you think,” he was told. “Your property has been sold for back taxes.”
 
As they would later learn, the problem went back almost 80 years but was uncovered only during a countywide property reassessment in 2000. Instead of four properties on their block, there were actually five. Joe kept paying on his old tax identification number, unaware that it no longer matched up with his house. Notices that his taxes were unpaid since roughly the beginning of this century were sent to “Ben Schroen/Groveland.” Mr. Schroen was the last guy listed on that lot. He bought the property sometime before 1918.
 
“I’m like, ‘You think the guy might be dead by now?’ ” Joe says.
 
Untangling this information sounds relatively easy now, but it took months of phone calls and meetings. Although the neighbors were initially told not to worry, they were finally advised to get an attorney. That worked. The problems got fixed. They don’t need to worry about losing their homes. But now they think it is only fair that the county cover more than $8,000 in attorney and engineering fees and other costs.
 
“Our tax dollars paid for the assessors,” says Ron. “So not only did we pay their salaries to not do their work, we had to turn around and pay to do their work for them.”
 
That’s triple salt in the wound. During the same time they were cleaning up this mess, Tazewell County’s supervisor of assessments, Mac Shoopman, retired under heavy fire for problems with late tax bills. He still was paid more than $1,000 a week in severance pay through the end of November. And the company cleaning up his problems is the same one that triggered the Groveland nightmare with the 2000 reassessment. And the tax scavenger who almost booted Joe was repaid his costs - plus interest.
 
“And we’re still paying taxes,” concludes Vickie Haven.
 
Under the circumstances, repaying somewhere between $8,000 to $10,000 seems more than fair, not to mention cheap. But the neighbors last talked to the county a couple of weeks ago. They still didn’t feel they were getting a real answer. (And Joe’s dad is on the County Board. So much for influence.)
 
“Shouldn’t we be able to know why?” Joe says. “It’s our money.”
 
County Board chairman Jim Unsicker sympathizes.
 
“This is one of the most bizarre situations I’ve ever seen. I’ve seen property lines be off, but we’re not talking about a couple feet here,” Unsicker says. “To say a person would be upset would be an understatement.”
 
He confirms Ron Haven’s observation that the county is not legally obligated to pay these bills. But there are other kinds of obligation.
 
“Doing the right thing is probably the bigger issue - that’s me talking,” Unsicker says. “Just because you don’t have to do something doesn’t mean you shouldn’t do it.”
 
Fortunately or unfortunately, the County Board is also responsible for the public checkbook. The chairman doesn’t want to set a precedent that could bite everybody later. So he referred me to Tazewell County State’s Attorney Stewart Umholtz.
 
“As a state’s attorney I can advise them they have no legal obligation - and you have to be careful as public officials,” Umholtz says. “Any time you as a government pay out money you’re not required to pay, you’re setting a precedent.”
 
But there are different kinds of precedents, as well. Umholtz leaves the door cracked open.
 
“Does that precedent set a legal obligation?” he says. “I would argue not.”
 
Doing the right thing would take some creativity. But perhaps a unique settlement can be tailored to fit a unique situation. These folks have gone through enough already.
 
TERRY BIBO is a columnist with the Journal Star. She can be reached at tbibo@pjstar.com, 686-3189, or 1-800-225-5757, Ext. 3189.