|
FAQ: When Google is not your friend
[Link is Broken]
http://news.zdnet.com/2100-9588_22-6034666.html
By Declan McCullagh, CNET News.com Published on ZDNet News: February 3,
2006, 4:00 AM PT
Google’s recent legal spat with the U.S. Department of Justice highlights
not only what information search engines record about us but also the
shortcomings in a federal law that’s supposed to protect online privacy.
It’s only a matter of time before other attorneys realize that a person’s
entire search history is available for the asking, and the subpoenas begin to
fly. This could happen in civil lawsuits or criminal prosecutions.
That type of fishing expedition is not legally permitted for Web mail
providers. But because search engines are not fully shielded by the 1986
Electronic Communications Privacy Act—concocted back in the era of CompuServe
and bulletin board systems—their users don’t enjoy the same level of privacy.
“Back then, providers were very different animals than they are now,” says
Paul Ohm, a former Justice Department attorney who teaches computer crime law at
the University of Colorado at Boulder.
Two solutions are simple to describe, but not likely to happen. First,
search engines could voluntarily—or be required by law to—delete search
histories after a few months unless the customer objects. Second, federal law
could be amended to make it clear that search engines, which serve as a window
to the Internet, are fully protected.
CNET News.com has surveyed Google, Microsoft, Yahoo and AOL to find out
their privacy practices, and assembled these answers to frequently asked
questions.
Q: Does Google collect and record people’s search terms whether
they’re logged in or not? Yes. Google confirmed this week that it
keeps and collates these results, which means the company can be forced to
divulge them under court order. Whether Google does anything else with them is
another issue.
Given the Department of Justice’s recent subpoena to Google, it’s likely
the police or even lawyers in civil cases—divorce attorneys, employers in
severance disputes—eventually will demand that Google, Microsoft, Yahoo, AOL,
and other search engines cough up users’ search histories.
Q: Has this happened before? Almost. A North Carolina
man was found guilty of murder in November in part because he Googled the words
“neck,” “snap,” “break” and “hold” before his wife was killed. But those search
terms were found on Robert Petrick’s computer, not obtained from Google
directly.
Also, attorneys have already begun introducing searches conducted on
Google, Yahoo and AltaVista as evidence.
Q: When I use search engines, I type in a lot of search terms I
consider private. What does this mean? We go into all the details
below. But the short answer is that when private companies collect reams of data
all the time on nearly every American, and the government and curious attorneys
can get to that with few obstacles, this becomes a problem. Search engines
provide a look into people’s personal lives, and privacy awareness has not kept
pace.
Q: Aren’t there any privacy laws that protect us? Not
really. There is a federal law called the Electronic Communications Privacy Act.
But it was enacted in 1986, long before politicians knew about the Internet, and
the wording doesn’t prevent police and attorneys from targeting search engines.
Politicians wrote that law in a way that is technology-specific—one key
part revolves around the meaning of the pre-Internet term “processing
services”—instead of adopting a more flexible approach that would grow with
technology. Some states may have laws that are more applicable.
Q: Why does Google store that information about me,
anyway? No law requires Google to delete it, and there are some
business justifications for keeping it.
For instance, keeping detailed records can help in identifying click fraud
(faking clicks on Web ads to drive up a rival’s cost), and in optimizing search
results for different geographic areas. Compiling a user profile can aid in
tailoring search results in products like Google Personalized Search. Also, disk
storage is cheap, and engineers tend to prefer to keep data rather than delete
it. But it’s hardly clear that a compelling reason exists for keeping
older records—beyond a few months—unless a customer voluntarily chooses
options like personalization.
Q: Does that mean Google has the technical ability to link a
person’s searches together and divulge them when legally
required? Yes. Google says in its FAQ that it records Internet
address, date, time, browser type, operating system and a cookie ID.
Author and entrepreneur John Battelle received word from Google this week
that the company can perform two important types of matches. (We confirmed this
with Google and followed up with additional questions.)
First, given a number of search terms, Google can produce a list of people
(identified by Internet address or cookie) who searched for a given term.
Second, given a collection of Internet addresses, Google can produce a list of
the terms searched by the user of a given address. That effectively creates an
electronic dossier of an individual.
Q: What about other search engines? We surveyed AOL,
Microsoft and Yahoo as well. Microsoft and Yahoo gave us the same response as
Google did.
AOL’s was a little different. Spokesman Andrew Weinstein said AOL could
provide a list of search terms typed in by a user. But AOL does not have a
system in place to perform the opposite mapping, which would find out what users
typed in which search terms. Weinstein also said that AOL deletes personally
identifiable search data after 30 days, which makes it unique among the quartet
we surveyed.
Q: What about links people click on from search engine results? Can
that information be turned over too? Yes. Through a process known as
redirection, Yahoo and AOL record what links people click. Unless the companies
discard these records, they would be fair game for a subpoena.
Q: Let’s say the Bush administration wanted to obtain a list of the
names or Internet addresses of anyone who typed “how to grow marijuana” or “how
to cheat on income taxes” into Google. Could that be done?
Probably. If the Electronic Communications Privacy Act does not apply, all
that’s required is a subpoena from a prosecutor, and no prior approval from a
judge is necessary. One Harvard law professor calls the subpoena power “akin to
a blank check.”
“The threshold rule is relevance,” says Paul Ohm, the University of
Colorado law professor. “Relevance has been quite broadly construed. As long as
you can show that something’s relevant to a case or criminal investigation, I
think the litigant would have a pretty good argument.”
Using the examples of finding out who did searches like “how to make meth”
or “how to kill the president,” Ohm says prosecutors “would have a very good
argument that it’s relevant to an investigation.”
Q: How can I protect my privacy from search
engines? First, to protect your privacy if your computer is stolen,
you can clear your browser’s history (sometimes called “private data”). In
Firefox, select that option from the Tools menu and delete your browsing history
and saved form information. Apple Computer’s Safari has a similar option under
the History menu. Encrypting your hard drive through OS X’s FileVault or PGP’s
Whole Disk Encryption may be a good idea.
Second, you can clear the cookies that are set by search engines. In
Firefox, go to Preferences and select Privacy. You have the option to delete
cookies and even prevent certain sites from ever setting them again. Be warned,
though, that adding Google.com to the list may prevent using options like
personalization or Gmail.
Third, if you’re really worried, go to Anonymizer.com and sign up for one
of its anonymous browsing options (they’re primarily for Windows users). Tor is
another option.
Danny Sullivan has posted a more extensive list of recommendations at
SearchEngineWatch.com.
Q: Is Congress going to do anything? Rep. Ed Markey, a
Massachusetts Democrat, has pledged to introduce legislation to prevent storing
search terms “beyond a reasonable period of time.”
There are some political and practical problems with this approach. First,
Markey is a liberal Democrat in a town controlled by Republicans, so his
proposal isn’t going anywhere. Second, any such law could be wildly
disruptive—it could mean class-action lawyers would get rich suing tech
companies on charges that their data-retention duration is not “reasonable.”
Finally, it’s hardly clear that the Bush administration will embrace such a
proposal—search terms could prove useful in criminal prosecutions, and the
Justice Department seems to like the ability to demand them from search engines.
Q: How are Internet addresses handed out? Do people always have the
same one? It depends. Many DSL and cable modem providers allocate
Internet addresses only when they’re in use (the methods are called DHCP and
PPPoe). Those IP addresses can change frequently.
Other IP addresses tend to be fixed. Faculty and staff members at
universities, and employees of corporations, are more likely to have fixed
Internet addresses.
Q: If Google knows I’m connecting from a dynamically assigned
Internet address of 192.1.1.1 one day, and 192.2.2.2 the next day and 192.3.3.3
the third, how can it link my queries together to create that
dossier? This is where “cookies” come in. A cookie is simply a
device for a Web site to recognize people the next time they return. Google,
Yahoo, AOL and Microsoft all set cookies by default. (Microsoft’s expire in
2016; Yahoo’s in 2010; Google’s in 2038. AOL sets a third-party cookie that
expires in 2011.)
In the above example, Google.com would set a cookie for whoever’s
connecting from Internet address 192.1.1.1 the first day, and then figure out
that the same Web browser is connecting from 192.2.2.2 and 192.3.3.3 the next
two days. If people are logged in to their Google account, this makes the
process even easier, of course.
Q: Even if a search engine company knows my Internet address is
192.1.1.1, and links my previous searches together, how can they—or the
government—get my name, home address or other information? If you
have a Google account for products like Gmail, Google Groups, Personalized
Search or Google Alerts, Google knows your e-mail address and other personal
information, which it can be forced to disclose. If a Web publisher signs up for
Google AdSense for advertising revenue, Google will have the publisher’s real
name, mailing address and Social Security Number.
If a person doesn’t use any other Google services, all the company can
divulge in response to a subpoena is that person’s Internet address. Then
whoever’s asking about the person will send a second subpoena to the person’s
Internet service provider to find out billing information. This is a relatively
straightforward procedure used by the Recording Industry Association of America
(RIAA) in thousands of file-swapping lawsuits.
Q: Has anyone ever sent search engines a subpoena or other kind of
legal request for someone’s search terms? We don’t know. Google and
Yahoo refused to answer the question, though there is no law prohibiting them
from doing so.
AOL said only that the Electronic Communications Privacy Act would apply.
Microsoft was by far the most forthcoming. With the exception of the Justice
Department subpoena for search terms (without user identities) last year,
Microsoft said it has “not received either criminal or civil requests related to
MSN Search data.”
Microsoft also said it “has never received either criminal or civil
requests” to produce the lists of people who typed in a search term. Oddly, the
other companies were not nearly as open.
Q: How long do companies keep records of my search
terms? Microsoft, Google and Yahoo all said they keep data as long
as it’s necessary, which could mean forever. Microsoft did add that the company
is “looking at ways” to provide users with the option to delete their search
histories, and Yahoo made a similar statement.
AOL, on the other hand, says it deletes personally identifiable data after
30 days.
CNET News.com’s Elinor Mills contributed to this report.
|