December 27, 2006
 
Mr. Michael Legel
22023 Allentown Rd.
Tremont, IL 61568
 
Dear Mr. Legel:
 
Thank you for contacting me about network neutrality. I appreciate having your thoughts on this issue.
 
Net neutrality is a principle holding that Internet access providers should not be permitted to engage in favoritism when configuring their networks and delivering Internet content. Such favoritism could occur if a provider transmitted its own offerings at faster speeds than those of its competitors or if a provider charged digital content and application companies a fee for equally fast delivery.
 
This issue has gained attention recently as several telecommunications company executives have made statements raising concerns that delivery may be impaired for content providers unwilling to pay additional fees for fast transmission. Many of these executives later clarified that they have no intention of degrading or blocking other traffic, particularly if it might prompt customers to switch to other providers, but merely wish to offer video delivery to their own customer base at a premium service level unavailable to non-paying competitors. Some in the industry have favorably compared additional network performance tiers to airlines selling coach and business class tickets or package delivery companies offering ground and air service. Other observers have expressed concern about the impact of such steps on consumers.
 
Two telecommunications bills before Congress have attracted attention because of their omission of comprehensive language related to network neutrality. On June 8, 2006, the House of Representatives passed the Communications Opportunity, Promotion, and Enhancement (COPE) Act of 2006, H.R. 5252. On June 28, 2006, the Senate Commerce Committee passed its own, different version of H.R. 5252. The Senate bill was previously known as the Communications, Consumer’s Choice, and Broadband Deployment Act of 2006, S. 2686.
 
The House and Senate bills only briefly touch on network neutrality. The Senate measure would establish an “Internet Consumer Bill of Rights” to guarantee that Internet subscribers can freely access all legal Web sites and services - including online calling services and video sites that compete with phone and cable companies’ own offerings. But it would not bar broadband providers from favoring their own online traffic or striking business deals with some Internet companies to guarantee fast, reliable access to their customers.
 
The House bill would offer the FCC limited power to enforce an earlier, non-binding set of broadly worded network neutrality principles it adopted in late 2005. The FCC would only be able to act if a complaint alleging a specific violation were to be filed, and it could not adopt or implement rules to carry out the principles.
 
Opponents of network neutrality argue that a regime prohibiting “bit discrimination” would deny network operators the opportunity to differentiate their services from other providers, thereby stifling the incentive to create innovative content for their customers. They also argue that network operators may face greater difficulties in raising the funding necessary for planned infrastructure upgrades if the improved network speeds would benefit their competitors as much as themselves.
 
Proponents of network neutrality - including major Internet content providers, hardware and software companies, and consumer groups - point to the money that operators already receive from end user and content provider access fees, the technological innovation that network neutrality may encourage, and the lack of high-speed Internet access marketplace competition that leaves much of the country with little opportunity to switch providers if their current provider were to engage in bit discrimination against the services or applications preferred by consumers.
 
I will keep your thoughts in mind in case H.R. 5252 is debated on the Senate floor. Thank you again for your message. Please keep in touch.
 
Sincerely,
 
Richard J. Durbin
United States Senator
RJD/
 
P.S. If you are ever visiting Washington, please feel free to join Senator Obama and me at our weekly constituent coffee. When the Senate is in session, we provide coffee and donuts every Thursday at 8:30 a.m. as we hear what is on the minds of Illinoisans and respond to your questions. We would welcome your participation. Please call my D.C. office for more details.