|
Illegal Immigration and the Death of America
[Link is Broken]
http://www.geocities.com:80/hiddenfire88/Immigration.htm
It’s true that America was founded on the backs of immigrants (those who
emigrated here voluntarily, and those who were enslaved). It’s true that
our entire society was created on a basis of ownership of land that victimized
Native Americans at the barrel of a gun. And it’s true that our ethnic and
cultural diversity is a strength as far as most of us are concerned. All
of these historical truths, plus a dollop of Christian hope and charity, are
being used by the ruling class in America (the wealthy) to transform America and
to destroy what it has become.
George W Bush stands before the American people and, not for the first
time, lies to our faces. He takes every opportunity to imply to us that we
have two basic choices : start a massive deportation program for illegal aliens,
or provide them with a “path to citizenship” that includes amnesty for their
illegal status. He carefully makes no mention of a third option – one that
when presented to Americans they support in large numbers – the option of
enforcing current US law, thereby creating an unfriendly climate for illegal
immigrants, which will result in diminished influx and in mass exodus.
Bush and the elites in both political parties propogate the impression that
enforcement of current law is in some way undoable or undesirable. You
would think that “Operation Wetback” had never happened under Eisenhower
(President Eisenhower faced the same problem, mass corruption and illegal
immigration, and responded by empowering law enforcement officials to deport
illegal aliens – see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Wetback)
a mere 52 years ago. And you would never know from the picture most of our
mass media outlets draw that most Americans strongly favor enforcement of
current law – see the polling data at [Link is Broken]http://www.cis.org/articles/2006/2006pollrelease.html
.
Instead of confronting our problems head-on, we seem stuck in an era of
political correctness where problems that intersect in any way with
race/ethnicity are not discussed honestly. I don’t subscribe to that
philosophy of life, so let me point out a few undeniable truths.
We already have poverty in America. We don’t need more poor
people. Yet that is what we are importing from Mexico every day, their
uneducated underclass. We can’t absorb it without either substantially
raising the tax burden of Middle-class Americans, or denying welfare benefits to
U.S. citizens who would otherwise qualify. You can’t wage a war on
poverty and at the same time allow tens of million more poor into the country –
people who frequently can’t speak English, lack so much as a high school
education, and have no reasonable hope to advance past menial jobs. Better
I think to pay a few dollars more and to hire Americans to do those jobs.
If we’re going to go in the other direction though, as our President and
Congressional Leaders would like to see (such as Nancy Pelosi, who owns a
vineyard staffed by illegal immigrants) then we should have some estimate of
cost, of the permanent cost of providing food stamps, free education and health
care, and other benefits for this permanent underclass that we are
building.
Am I worrying too much? Would this President and our Congress put us
into a bad place without thinking through the consequences? Ask our
soldiers in Iraq about that one, ask them who in this government ever looks out
for or looked out for their interests.
Do illegal aliens use welfare? Yes – check out the report at [Link is Broken]http://www.cis.org/articles/2003/back503release.html
. Do they take out more than they put in? About $2700 a year per
household headed by an illegal alien – see http://www.cis.org/articles/2004/fiscal.html
. What would the cost be of the type of Amnesty that President Bush and
the U.S. Senate proposed last year? Absolutely massive, on a scale
that dwarfs other ostensible issues such as Bush’s “Social Security reform”
issue of a couple of years ago. (Or the vaccines issue, or the manned
mission to Mars issue, that he distracted us with recently).
If our ostensible war on poverty (the one that Democrats pretend to fight)
isn’t real, what about the war on crime, the struggle to keep life safer?
Well, guess what. The illegal immigrants who come to our country might be
happy to exist as a slave class, and work multiple jobs for low salaries, but
their children who grow up next to the rest of us are generally less thrilled at
the prospect. It’s a no-brainer that the importation of poverty leads to
more crime and less safe cities. You can read about the crime rate in
sanctuary cities up at http://www.cis.org/articles/2004/back704.html
.
What about Bush’s concept, and the general liberal precept, of “No Child
Left Behind”? If our schools can’t figure out how to serve our own
children, throwing tens of millions more children raised in poverty into the mix
can’t be a good thing, especially when so many of those children have special
needs, i.e. they don’t learn English at home. Are we allowing this
because we have plans for a massive influx of money into the school
system? Or because we have systematically figured out a way to serve all
our children, and leave none behind? Hardly. We’re allowing it to
happen despite the rather obvious fact that it means many more native children
will end up “left behind” – and at that, left behind in a nation to compete with
millions of Mexico’s poor, frequently unable to make the type of honest livings
with manual labor that many of our fathers and grandfathers did.
Would we miss the illegal immigrants if their “Day Without Illegals”
(remember the marches last Spring, where pro-illegal groups did their best to
mimic and appropriate the Civil Rights movement in America and the
African-American experience/struggle? Ironic given the effect if illegal
immigration on black neighborhoods and black employment) became a year, decade,
or some other extended period of time without them? I hardly think
so. We as Americans are quite capable of building houses, digging ditches,
doing landscape work, and so forth. If the price of lettuce goes up 10
cents a head, I’ll gladly pay it to preserve my way of life and preserve our
social contract with other Americans. At that, I for one would like to see
teenagers able to get part-time jobs again, something that was true in America’s
past but less true since they’ve had to compete with millions of unschooled
aliens with no obligations other than to work at McDonald’s or wherever – see
the report up at [Link is Broken]http://www.cis.org/articles/2006/back806.html
for a discussion of how illegal immigration has affected young Americans.
To me, this is rather clearly the issue of our times. The war in Iraq
seems to dominate headlines and dominate current politics, though in a sense –
no disrespect to America’s soldiers, trapped in an unnecessary war without an
achievable mission – that is yesterday’s news, the blunder was already committed
by the President and Congress, and validated by the American public in the 2004
elections. The next major blunder, one with I think wider and deeper
implications, is being committed right now.
The Democratic party maintains allegiance from most of its voters by
pledging to fight against poverty, by pledging to restore dignity to America’s
working poor, and by claiming to fight for a better education and better working
future for our young. Clearly the influx of illegal immigrants, and the
Senate’s proposed amnesty, undercuts each of these goals. I cannot fathom
why this has not occurred to more Democratic voters, why they don’t demand some
level of accountability and policy definition from their party. Instead
they accept the Congressional leadership of Nancy Pelosi – who personally
profiteers from illegal labor in her vineyards – and Harry Reid, who once gave
an eloquent speech about the need to diminish illegal immigration in America,
but subsequently 180-ed around saying the his wife had caused him to change his
beliefs (he now calls that speech the “low point” of his career - [Link is Broken]http://jcrue.wordpress.com/2006/04/06/reid-flip-flops-on-immigration-demonstrating-his-opinions-depend-on-politics-and-not-reality/
).
The Republican party ostensibly stands for fiscal responsibility,
conservatism in social policy, and uniform enforcement of U.S. law in
keeping with a non-activist framework (preserving many rights to States, not to
the federal government). They’re prepared under the leadership of Bush,
John McCain, and party insiders like Karl Rove and Mel Martinez, to broker an
amnesty deal that will result in tens of millions more U.S. poor on our
welfare rolls, as well as encouraging continued influx from Mexico and other
nations. They’re prepared to deliver this as a death blow to our welfare
system, and probably also to our Social Security system. (Many Republicans
would welcome the death of these programs). They see the influx as key to
growth, the addition to this country of a cheap labor pool that can fuel
growth. The side effects of increased poverty, crime, and overcrowding –
the degradation of American standard of life (already visible in cities with
large illegal immigrant populations ) – as well as the side effects mentioned
above, which make a joke of most of our social policy and planning of the last
40 years - do not disturb many Republicans, who live in gated communities in the
first place or who rather directly profit from the cheap labor pool which they
have been forcing the average American taxpayer to subsidize against their own
best interests.
Beyond the two parties, which are each revealed (to me at least) as
collections of power-grubbing worms devoid of values, I am bothered by the
breaking of the social contract that once held America together. Wars have
been fought and many lives sacrificed to make America what it is. Those
sacrifices were made by individuals for their country and for their children and
grandchildren. A nation was created where we had a social contract to
collectively struggle to provide opportunity for all Americans, yes even the
ones who lack college degrees. Too many Americans care little about the
welfare of their fellow citizens, fail to care whether their ability to make a
decent living is impacted by the phenomenon of mass illegal immigration and the
encouragement of it. We’re eager to start wars in Iraq for perceived
self-interest and to sacrifice our young, but seem to care hardly a whit about
those soldiers’ economic future in future decades. Will Americans really
abandon each other over 10 cents for a head of lettuce? Are we really
content to absorb a new permanent underclass and swell the ranks of the
poor?
Do we now feel that at this point in history we are unable to
support each other, or to maintain pride in being an American? And in
American labor and products? Has that become passé, has the Bush family
ushered us into the era of “global capitalism”?
The history of America is largely one of the rich bamboozling the poor,
using side issues such as “gay marriage” or “flag burning” to successfully tempt
middle-class Americans to vote against their economic self-interest. As of
this moment, the elites who run things are pulling the wool over the American
peoples’ eyes enough to openly consider measures on immigration which will
destroy what this nation is – by that I mean, destroy the social safety net and
destroy our sense of community and dignity of labor. It disgusts me, and I
hope you will reflect on the points I’ve highlighted long enough to become
disgusted yourself. And I hope that when this current duplicitous snake
leaves his office, that we can collectively insist from our next leader or
anyone who aspires to be (Obama? McCain? Clinton?) that they speak
directly and rationally to us about immigration. The current President has
dedicated himself to a path of obfuscation and outright dishonesty, guised as
“compassionate conservatism”, i.e. Christian charity. Has he planned
out the costs to this nation? Probably about as well as he planned the war
in Iraq.
|