Illegal immigration hurts America’s poor
They compete more for jobs and get paid less for them
08:21 AM CST on Saturday, January 6, 2007
There’s a popular game in America that goes, I’ll cut your wages, but you
don’t cut mine. And the outsourcing of your factory job to China is a good thing
because it makes my paycheck go further at Wal-Mart. We hear this theme a lot in
the debate over illegal immigration.
Consider the recent raids on Swift meat-processing plants. Federal agents
arrested 1,187 illegal immigrants at facilities in six states. Mere hours later,
economists warned that depriving the industry of illegal labor could raise
hamburger prices.
Illegal immigration is usually presented as a win-win situation:
Undocumented foreigners earn far more than they could back home. Consumers get a
bargain.
Nowhere to be seen are America’s working poor, who get stomped on 13
different ways. They have to compete with illegal immigrants for jobs and
housing. Low-skilled natives and legal immigrants also end up subsidizing the
undocumented because they tend to live in the same communities, which must
provide hospitals, police, schools and garbage pickup.
Who doesn’t suffer from illegal immigration? For starters, the people who
write about it. I speak of the journalism profession, which has the habit of
covering the issue with sympathetic stories about illegal immigrants who work
hard and go to church.
But were a busload of illegals from Australia to turn up and offer
reportage at 10 percent below the going rate, the writers would call the
authorities so fast your head would spin. And the publisher’s argument that
thanks to the cheap Australians, he’s able to trim a few cents off the newsstand
price would make no impression.
As it turns out, the meat-processing companies that employ so many illegal
immigrants have been enjoying a nearly 50 percent discount on what was the going
rate. In 1980, the average meat-processing job paid $19 an hour. The companies
then moved their plants to rural areas, far from the Midwest cities and their
unions. The average wage now? About $9 an hour.
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce likes to wail about the “labor shortage.” It
says there aren’t enough chambermaids, dishwashers, etc. to work for its members
at lousy wages. Odd, but when there’s a shortage of labor – or anything else –
doesn’t the price of it go up? The price of unskilled labor in the United States
hasn’t gone up. It’s gone down. Because of immigration, American-born high
school dropouts experienced a 5 percent loss in wages during the ’80s and ’90s,
according to a study by Harvard economist George Borjas.
For some reason, the job of keeping prices low has fallen entirely on the
shoulders of the most vulnerable Americans. If we banged down CEO compensation
and sliced lawyers’ pay by a third, the same thing would happen. Everyone’s
prices would drop. The corporation could sell its products for less, and the
cost of legal services would fall.
Suggest a U.S. labor policy that depresses professional pay as a means of
keeping prices in check, and you get laughed out of the room. But say that
sitting on the wages of unskilled factory workers stems inflationary pressure –
a frequently made argument – and the PhDs quietly nod in agreement.
And that’s how the game is played. High pay for me. Low pay for you. The
folks at the economic bottom are obviously not making the rules.
Froma Harrop writes for The Providence Journal, a Belo newspaper. Her
e-mail address is
fharrop@projo.com.