|
High Court to Decide Uses for Union Dues
By DONNA GORDON BLANKINSHIP Associated Press Writer
January 7, 2007, 2:12 PM EST SEATTLE — The man whose name is
on a labor-limiting lawsuit the U.S. Supreme Court is to hear this week says
politics, not a dislike of unions, kept him from joining up when he got his
teaching job in 1998.
Former high school social studies teacher Gary Davenport said the principle
of standing up for himself and his colleagues, however, is why he agreed to be
the lead plaintiff in a case that could set or expand the boundaries of labor
activism just before the 2008 presidential campaign.
“This has been going on and will continue to go on to those teachers who
don’t have a voice,” said Davenport, 32. “They really don’t have an opportunity
to defend themselves or protect their own money. They’ve kind of been bullied by
the unions.”
The Evergreen Freedom Foundation, a conservative think tank, sought out
Davenport and other nonmember teachers after fighting for years with the
Washington Education Association over the union’s collection of fees from
workers who choose not to join.
Those teachers can be charged a fee for labor negotiations that affect
them, but they can’t be forced to pay for the union’s political activism, under
a series of Supreme Court rulings reaching back nearly 30 years.
The money in question is minimal — about $10 for each of about 3,000
nonmember teachers.
At issue in Wednesday’s arguments is whether the union needs teachers to
say “yes” before the fees can be used for political causes or whether teachers
must specifically object to having a portion of the fees spent for that purpose.
Observers say a ruling in the union’s favor could open the door to labor efforts
elsewhere to roll back limits on the use of dues.
The union maintains it has followed campaign finance laws and claims its
reputation has been damaged by the ongoing legal challenge despite winning the
case in lower courts.
“It seemed to stick more in the public’s mind that we were accused of
violating campaign finance laws,” union president Charles Hasse said.
The union is the state’s largest teachers union, representing teachers and
other employees of public schools and colleges. Less than 5 percent of the
80,000 people the union represents choose not to be members, the union said.
The case and another being heard along with it are Gary Davenport v.
Washington Education Association, 05-1589, and Washington v. Washington
Education Association, 05-1657.
|