|
Fat CEO pay seen a wider society concern
Fri Jan 5, 2007 3:57pm ET NEW YORK (Reuters) - Criticism of massive
payouts for chief executives is no longer only for union activists and
investors. The phenomenon now has professors of ethics asking what it says about
modern human behavior and politicians looking to curb excesses.
Many say the trend is only growing more extreme. While business leaders
have always done well — the 19th century robber barons like John D. Rockefeller
and Andrew Carnegie amassed huge fortunes — those tycoons actually owned big
parts of their companies. They also ultimately gave much of their wealth
away.
Today, soaring executive pay “offends most people’s sense of fairness,”
said Archie Carroll, a recently retired business ethics professor at the
University of Georgia.
It “symbolizes more than anything else how out of touch corporate America,
particularly CEOs and boards of directors,, is with the rest of American
society,” he said.
The abrupt departure of Home Depot Inc. (HD.N: Quote, Profile , Research)
chief Robert Nardelli this week, with a $210 million exit package in hand, shows
how skewed CEO pay can be, ethics experts say.
Nardelli’s exit package, which includes $20 million cash severance as well
as a pension, deferred stock awards and stock options, equals the annual incomes
of about 10,000 retail stock clerks making an average $21,000 a year.
In 2005, the ratio of CEO pay to average worker pay was 411-to-1, according
to a report by the Institute for Policy Studies and United for a Fair Economy,
two groups that focus on social justice issues. That compares with a 1980 ratio
of 42-to-1, as calculated by BusinessWeek, the two groups said.
The huge gap between Nardelli’s exit pay — which excludes the millions in
salary and bonus he collected over his six-year tenure — versus the earnings of
low-wage workers, goes against what philosophers such as Plato would consider
acceptable in a just society, said philosophy professor Michael Boylan of
Marymount University in Arlington, Virginia.
Plato was concerned about a small group of people at the top of society
taking all of the wealth, said Boylan, who has written a book suggesting that
companies pay their chiefs no more than 50 times what the lowest paid employee
makes.
What’s particularly galling in the Home Depot case, investor activists say,
is that the stock fell 8 percent under Nardelli’s leadership, trailing chief
rival Lowe’s Cos. Inc. (LOW.N: Quote, Profile , Research), which has paid its
CEO much less.
Nardelli, who hasn’t commented on the terms of his departure, is not the
only U.S. chief to get a huge payout. Pfizer Inc. has been under fire for giving
ousted CEO Hank McKinnell an exit package worth an estimated $198 million.
Hewlett-Packard Co.’s Carly Fiorina, Tom Freston of Viacom Inc. and Philip
Purcell of Morgan Stanley, also collected millions when they were shown the
door.
Politicians have gotten involved in some cases. New York’s attorney
general’s office has sued former New York Stock Exchange Chairman Richard Grasso
over the $187.5 million in compensation he received, saying his pay was
unreasonable under state law.
And U.S. House Financial Services Committee Chairman Barney Frank said
Nardelli’s severance was “further confirmation of the need to deal with a
pattern of CEO pay that appears to be out of control.”
HOW MUCH IS A CEO WORTH?
So why do companies pay their executives so much? Free-market advocates
argue that top CEOs are in such short supply that boards of directors are
willing to pay whatever it takes to get the candidate of their choice.
Others, though, contend that pay is artificially high, in part because
other well-paid CEOs tend to be on company boards and approve executive
compensation.
It’s not just CEOs who are handsomely rewarded in today’s society. Movie
stars and professional athletes also can earn huge payouts. Elsewhere in
business, hedge fund managers and top Wall Street traders can earn even more
than big-name executives.
The famed industrialists of the late 19th and early 20th centuries, like
Rockefeller, Carnegie and financier J.P. Morgan, also accumulated vast sums.
Still, experts say there is a big difference between those men and today’s
CEOs.
Rockefeller, Carnegie and other business tycoons were typically the
founders of their companies and owned the bulk of them, unlike most chiefs today
who are hired to run corporations and paid on the shareholders’ dime.
Tycoons like Rockefeller were criticized at the time not so much for how
much money they made — in part because no one knew exactly how much that was —
but for the enormous power they wielded, said financial historian Richard Sylla,
a professor at New York University’s Stern School Business.
He said Rockefeller, for example, had the power to make the railroads give
him better transport rates than his rivals got.
Rockefeller and others also gave away much of their wealth. Some of today’s
businessmen also have given a lot to charity, such as Microsoft Corp.’s Chairman
Bill Gates and Berkshire Hathaway Inc. CEO Warren Buffett.
Even if more of this generation’s CEOs end up sharing their wealth, that
doesn’t help explain their huge salaries, some ethics experts say.
“I don’t know of any ethical theory in my training in philosophy that would
justify some of the pay that we are seeing,” said Norman Bowie, a business
ethics professor at the University of Minnesota. “There is a tremendous sense of
entitlement out there on the part of CEOs.”
|