Statewide smoking ban on the table

If legislation passes, Illinois would prohibit
lighting up in all indoor public areas

 
Friday, January 12, 2007
 
By Laura Camper
of Copley News Service
 
SPRINGFIELD - Calling secondhand smoke “a silent but very deadly killer that’s robbing Illinois of our very best,” state Sen. John Cullerton on Thursday proposed a statewide smoking ban.  The bill would, with exceptions for some home-based businesses, ban smoking in all workplaces and indoor public places. If the legislation passes, Cullerton said, Illinois would join 16 other states, including California and New York, that already have bans in place.
 
In Springfield, which went smoke-free in September, some restaurant and bar owners say they have been hurt because neighboring towns have not imposed bans. Sen. Christine Radogno, R-Lemont, a co-sponsor of Senate Bill 500, said a statewide ban would level the playing field.
 
“If one town adopts a smoke-free ordinance, they are not disadvantaged by the town next to them that doesn’t have one,” she said.
 
However, Steve Riedl, executive director of the Illinois Licensed Beverage Association, said supporters of smoking bans have contended all along they would improve business, not hurt it, so there should be no reason to level the playing field.
 
“Obviously, they were lying,” he said.
 
A statewide ban “takes one wrong and multiplies it into a number of wrongs,” Riedl said, adding that banning smoking amounts to one group of people trying to force their beliefs on everyone else.
 
The same complaint came up during the debate over whether to require motorists to use seat belts, Cullerton said.
 
“People wanted the right to kill themselves,” he said, citing a statistic that eight people a day die from exposure to secondhand smoke, some of them in jobs where smoking is allowed. Working eight hours in a smoke-filled environment is the same as smoking 16 cigarettes, Cullerton said.
 
Harry Kelley, a lobbyist for the Illinois Association of Tobacco and Candy Distributors, pointed to The Curve Inn, a bar in Southern View. Because it is not subject to the smoking ban, the bar is so busy it has started to impose a cover charge on Friday and Saturday nights, he said.
 
Representatives of The Curve Inn could not be reached.
 
“When you quit selling cigarettes, it’s an economic issue,” Kelley said. “This is dollars and cents.”
 
But Lisa Cristia of Chicago, speaking at Thursday’s Statehouse news conference to announce the proposed statewide ban, said she believes it’s a health issue. Cristia, who said she never smoked a cigarette in her life, was diagnosed with smoker’s cancer in her early 30s. She had to have part of her tongue and 13 lymph nodes removed, as well as a tracheotomy.
 
She said she worked in bars and restaurants for 10 years - all her adult life - before being diagnosed.
 
“Ladies and gentlemen, I am a victim of secondhand smoke,” she said.
 
The bill would impose fines of $250 to $500 against businesses that do not comply with the smoking ban and $100 to $200 for individuals who break the law.
 
The enclosed beer gardens and tents being created by some Springfield bars and restaurants would not be exempt under the statewide ban, Cullerton said.
 

Laura Camper can be reached at (217) 782-6882 or laura.camper@sj-r.com.