|
Report: Officials improperly backed reading program
[Link is Broken]
http://www.cnn.com
POSTED: 11:53 a.m. EDT, March 23, 2007
WASHINGTON (AP) — Education Department officials and their contractors
appear to have improperly backed certain types of instruction in administering a
$1 billion-a-year reading program, congressional investigators found.
The Government Accountability Office report supports assertions by the
inspector general of the Education Department, who has released several reports
in recent months into the Reading First program.
The program is a key part of the 2002 No Child Left Behind law. It offers
intensive reading help for low-income and struggling schools.
The GAO, Congress’ investigative and auditing arm, surveyed states to get
their views on the program.
In a report due out Friday and obtained by The Associated Press, the GAO
states that some states said they received suggestions from federal officials or
contractors to adopt or eliminate certain programs or tests.
Federal law prohibits the department from requiring certain curricula or
directing states to use specific programs.
Officials “may have violated the statutory prohibition against mandating or
directing local curricular decisions by effectively endorsing or directing the
selection of particular Reading First programs,” the GAO said.
In 10 states, officials said they received suggestions to get rid of
certain programs or tests, according to the report. And officials in four states
said they received suggestions to adopt specific programs or tests, the GAO
said. The report did not name the states.
An inspector general report released late last year stated that the reading
program was beset by conflicts of interest and mismanagement. It found that
people who had clear conflicts of interest due to their industry connections
were able to serve as grant reviewers under the program.
The inspector general stated that the review panels were stacked with
people who shared the views of the former program director, Chris Doherty. The
report stated that Doherty repeatedly used his influence to steer money toward
states that used a reading approach he favored, called Direct Instruction.
The GAO reports that state officials believe reading instruction has
improved under the federal program due partly to the increased focus it placed
on reading efforts.
Deputy Education Secretary Ray Simon wrote in a response to the GAO report
that the department would take steps to avoid future problems.
“We will provide written guidance in the near future to all department
staff reminding them of the importance of impartiality in the performance of
their duties and not construing program statutes to authorize the department to
mandate, direct or control curriculum and instruction, except to the extent
authorized by law,” he wrote.
The No Child Left Behind law is scheduled to be rewritten this year, and
there has been some speculation on Capitol Hill as to whether the reading
program will be renewed.
The two lawmakers in charge of the committees that oversee education issues
say hearings into Reading First are likely.
“We must continue to investigate how Reading First was implemented to learn
from past mistakes and prevent future abuses,” said Rep. George Miller,
D-California, the chairman of the House committee.
“The GAO report confirms that the department failed to take appropriate
steps to give states clear guidance and impartial assistance in implementing
Reading First. Our students and teachers deserve better,” said Sen. Edward M.
Kennedy, D-Massachusetts, chairman of the Senate committee.
|