Congress seeks to overturn NLRB
‘Kentucky River’ ruling


By Mark Gruenberg
 
25 March 2007 WASHINGTON - In a move to protect millions of workers from being arbitrarily deprived of their rights on the job, three members of Congress introduced legislation  to overturn a National Labor Relations Board’s ruling that “workers are supervisors.”

The very short bill by House Employer-Employee Relations Subcommittee Chairman Robert Andrews, D-N.J., Rep. Don Young, R-Alaska, and Sen. Christopher J. Dodd, D-Conn., would order that a worker cannot be a supervisor unless “for a majority of the working time” he or she is “acting in the interest of the employer” in hiring, firing, disciplining or otherwise managing workers.
 
It also says a worker cannot be named a supervisor just for “assigning” other people to tasks or just for being responsible for directing them on occasion.
 
The legislation is designed to nullify last year’s NLRB ruling in what are called the Kentucky River cases, named after a nursing home which took the whole workers-as-supervisors issue to the Supreme Court years ago.
 
The justices ruled the NLRB had to clarify which workers, under labor law, are supervisors and thus not covered. Supervisors must follow management orders and can be hired or fired at will—and used in union-busting campaigns.
 
The Bush-named majority on the board used that High Court order to rule last September, in a case involving the Oakwood Nursing Home, that millions of workers, including 843,000 registered nurses nationwide, could be deemed supervisors, because they spent small portions of their time—as little as 10 percent-15 percent—in such “supervisory” duties as telling orderlies to change bedpans.
 
Oakwood also opened the way for employers to contend that other workers, including construction workers, newspaper reporters, kindergarten teachers, airplane pilots and physical therapists, could be ruled as supervisors and thus evicted from labor law. That would also make them unorganizable.
 
Estimates of the number of workers hit by the Bush board’s Oakwood ruling range from 8 million by the Economic Policy Institute to 34 million by the NLRB’s two dissenters.
 
EPI computations, using Labor Department data, show that 45.9 percent of all pilots, 34.8 percent of all registered nurses, 19 percent (49,500) kindergarten teachers and 12 percent (24,100) of all reporters would be affected.
 
That shows the impact of Kentucky River on white-collar as well as blue-collar or pink-collar occupations. The occupation that would get hit the worst, EPI calculated, is physicians’ assistants: 62.5 percent, or 53,700, would be declared “supervisors.”
 
AFL-CIO President John Sweeney said the new legislation “will right a wrong done to millions of Americans when the Bush-dominated labor board stripped away their right to bargain for better wages and benefits. The NLRB defied congressional intent by reclassifying as ‘supervisors’ many workers with only low-level supervisory duties, professionals such as nurses, and other skilled craftspersons.”
 
The new legislation “will restore Congress’s original intent, which was never to deny protection to these workers,” he declared.
 
The federation said the board “radically reinterpreted the definition of ‘supervisor’ in a way that greatly expanded the number and types of workers that can be classified as supervisors. The board ruled a worker can be classified as a supervisor if he or she spends as little as 10 percent to 15 percent of his or her time overseeing the work of others. That breaks down to less than an hour a day or one full shift every two weeks.”
 
In their lobbying for the new bill, unionists will stress Congress did not intend that low-level supervisors, professionals such as nurses and other skilled workers—including the construction workers—be left uncovered by labor law. Yet that is what the Bush majority of the NLRB did.
 
They’ll also note the proposed new law would put an end to almost 30 years of controversy over whether nurses are supervisors. That fight preceded the original Kentucky River case.
 
And the new bill would also say workers, such as charge nurses, who occasionally take on supervisory duties for a shift or two, are not supervisors, the fed’s talking points add. With such “charge nurses” and similar “team leaders” in other occupations becoming more and more frequent on the job, the board’s ruling could automatically make them supervisors—even though they spend little time supervising.