|
House bill would require paper ballots next year
[Link is Broken] http://www.sacbee.com
By David Whitney - Bee Washington Bureau Published 12:00 am PDT
Saturday, March 24, 2007
Seeking to address concerns over the integrity of elections, a House panel
is weighing controversial legislation requiring states to bring back the paper
ballot as the official record.
Many, if not most, states are expressing concerns that Congress is moving
too fast with pending legislation that would take effect in time for the 2008
national presidential elections, with primary balloting beginning in
January.
Only 17 states have voter systems that would be in compliance with the
proposed law.
The legislation has divided advocacy groups. State elections officials are
opposed to it. County officials don’t like it.
Even among those who support the idea, including California Secretary of
State Debra Bowen, the consensus is it will cost a lot more money than
cash-strapped Congress may be prepared to spend.
“Three hundred million dollars is not enough, especially for states with
only touchscreen voting,” Bowen said of the bill, introduced by Reps. Rush Holt,
D-N.J., and Tom Petri, R-Wis.
In Florida last year, more than 18,000 ballots in Sarasota County
registered no votes for either congressional candidate seeking to replace former
Rep. Katherine Harris, one of the icons of the state’s 2000 presidential
election debacle.
But Florida is moving ahead without the federal legislation.
Florida Gov. Charlie Crist told the House Administration Committee’s
elections panel Friday that he has proposed replacing the state’s electronic
voting system with an optical scanner system.
Under that system, voters would mark paper ballots that would then be
scanned electronically for tabulation. But the paper ballot would remain to be
counted, and recounted, if there were a dispute.
Crist said that if the Legislature approves the system and funds it as he
expects, it will be in force by next year. He said voters will be able to leave
their polling places with full confidence that their ballot has been “counted,
recorded and available, if necessary.”
Bowen told the panel that California has required a paper trail for
electronic voting machines since 2004, and a mandatory 1 percent recount as a
form of auditing since 2006.
But California has a mixed system that under the Holt-Petri legislation
could require many counties to put in new equipment. The time counties have
taken to purchase such equipment has varied greatly — from a month or two in
Placer County to more than a year in San Francisco County.
“The last thing any of us want is to truncate public review of any system,
rushing through approval under the presumption that any solution is better than
the current system, only to find ourselves back here in two or three years
having the same discussion all over again,” Bowen said in a letter to the
committee.
Bowen has not taken a position on the legislation, her office said Friday.
Only four state secretaries of state are backing the legislation to date,
according to an aide to Rep. Zoe Lofgren, D-San Jose, the elections subcommittee
chairwoman.
Other elections officials said they felt Congress was making them
scapegoats.
“Elections officials feel like they are the targets in all this,”
complained George Gilbert, elections director of Guilford County, N.C.
Some members of the elections panel said paper ballots are no
panacea.
“Paper ballots are notoriously susceptible to fraud,” said Don Norris,
public policy professor at the University of Maryland.
Among the bill’s skeptics is Rep. Kevin McCarthy of Bakersfield. The former
California Assembly Republican leader is the senior Republican on the panel
despite being in his first year in Congress.
McCarthy said in he regards the legislation as an “unfunded mandate”
because it will impose huge costs on the state for replacing voting equipment
without sufficient federal reimbursement.
McCarthy said he thinks the bill process should be slowed down. “I take it
from all the witnesses that there’s still a lot of work to be done on this,” he
said.
But Lofgren, a co-sponsor of the legislation, believes something can be
worked out this year.
“It’s an aggressive schedule, but it’s possible,” Lofgren said.
|