School consolidation study dead

[Link is Broken]
http://www.pekintimes.com

By Tara Mattimoe
 
Published: Tuesday, March 27, 2007 2:43 PM CDT
 
PEKIN - After just under an hour of occasionally heated debate, the District 303 School Board voted down a comprehensive consolidation study involving District 108, District 303, and all the feeder districts in between.
 
 
The consolidation study would be extensive, lengthy, and would cost approximately $30,000 to conduct.
 
District 98, South Pekin District 137, Spring Lake District 606, North Pekin-Marquette Heights District 102 and Pekin District 108 school boards all would have to approve placing a measure on a ballot, either by school board approval or citizen petitions, before consolidation could even be considered.
 
None of the feeder districts has expressed an interest in consolidation, said District 303 Superintendent Paula Davis.
 
In December, District 108 decided against a consolidation study for its schools, at least for the time being.
 
Largely to blame for the difficulty of the consolidation issue, Davis said, is a faulty and confusing law currently on the books that did not take feeder districts into account.
 
Board member Jim Mangan, still in favor of the merger and leader of the group Citizens for Pekin School Consolidation, requested further debate on the subject at Monday night’s board meeting.
 
The motion was seconded by board member Mark Rossi.
 
“Everything financially shows that consolidation is a net gain,” Mangan said. “I think the public expects this and there doesn’t seem to be any logical reason not to pursue it.”
 
Rossi said that although it may take years to get the law rewritten (and a good argument can be made that they should wait, he added), voters did vote in favor of the study.
 
Rossi said he does “believe it is appropriate” to have it done, even if only for the information they could use in the future.
 
“Right now,” responded board member Karen Hohimer, “the law is so poorly written I would not waste one tax dollar on this study.”
 
A big incentive for the merger, Mangan said, would be improved scholastic performance by students, which he believes would indeed happen. However, even if it did not, he said, “it’s still a winner financially” and therefore the board should move ahead with it. The law will need to be changed before any consolidation can happen, said board member Joe Alesandrini, and the board has been told by legislators that it will take two to three years before the corrections go through.
 
“Whatever facts you have now in 2007 will not be worth a hill of beans in 2010,” Alesandrini said in support of waiting to do the consolidation study. In addition, Alesandrini said that the actual difference tax payers would see on property taxes were the consolidation to take place, would only be about $15 for a $100,000 house.
 
Mangan questioned the validity of this amount, saying that records show a tendency of the board’s “missing projections,” which tend to be advantageous to the district, but not the tax payer.
 
Davis said Mangan’s statements were accusatory and “patently unfair,” and pointed out that District 303 has gotten “the highest ratings possible over the course of the years” by the state, because of its financial responsibility.
 
Alesandrini called for a vote to end the debate, which all board members but Mangan and Rossi voted in favor of.
 
The motion to proceed with a consolidation study failed, with only Mangan and Rossi voting in favor.