|
Wal-Mart’s Big Apple dreams may be over
Cost, union hostility doom market entry
[Link is Broken] http://www.chicagotribune.com
Associated Press Published March 29, 2007
NEW YORK — Wal-Mart Stores Inc., embattled by failed attempts to open
stores in Queens and Staten Island, might be giving up on New York, or at the
very least Manhattan.
Chairman and Chief Executive H. Lee Scott said trying to conduct business
in New York was so expensive that “I don’t think it is worth the effort. I don’t
care if we are ever here.” His comments were in a story published Wednesday by
The New York Times.
But Wal-Mart officials on Wednesday quickly clarified that Scott, who in
the interview made repeated references to “New York,” was referring to
Manhattan, and not the entire city.
“We have never tried to get into Manhattan and aren’t sure we ever will
unless the economics of the specific deal make sense for us,” the company said.
“We would like to be in other boroughs if we can find the right arrangement,
because we know we could serve those communities very well.”
Still, Stuart Applebaum, president of the Retail, Wholesale and Department
Store Union, which is leading the charge against Wal-Mart in New York, said
Scott’s comments were good news for the union. The union represents 100,000
workers throughout the United States and Canada, including 45,000 workers in New
York.
“They are going to find that no matter where they are in New York City, the
response is going to be the same,” Applebaum said. “New Yorkers will not
tolerate their way of operating. Their promises of low prices come at too high
of a cost.”
Applebaum said that if Wal-Mart were able open in New York, it would mean
there “would be no place that would be off limits.”
Patricia Edwards, a portfolio manager and retail analyst at Wentworth,
Hauser & Violich in Seattle, noted that even if Wal-Mart writes off the New
York area, she doesn’t see it as a big financial blow.
“There are a lot of retailers that do quite well and they are not in New
York,” she said. While she said there’s certainly a huge demographic base,
stores face high property values and shipping costs.
Union-backed critics in New York, Chicago and elsewhere have waged a fierce
campaign against Wal-Mart, asserting that the retailer’s wages and benefits are
so modest they drive down pay and benefits for many of its competitors and force
employees to go on state-funded health-care plans.
Wal-Mart has denied union claims, asserting that it creates jobs and raises
the standard of living for many residents with its low prices.
Wal-Mart is looking to urban markets to fuel domestic growth. Those efforts
have been met with resistance from labor and neighborhood groups. The campaign
clashed with Wal-Mart in its failed attempts to open stores in Queens in 2004
and in Staten Island last year.
Wal-Mart entered Chicago last year, its biggest city, but only after Mayor
Richard Daley vetoed an ordinance requiring higher wages. In the interview with
Times, Scott said that the Wal-Mart store in Chicago has performed better than
expected.
Shares of Wal-Mart fell 85 cents, to $46.64, Wednesday on the New York
Stock Exchange.
|