|
Split court rules against Bush on greenhouse gases
[Link is Broken] http://www.cnn.com
POSTED: 11:49 a.m. EDT, April 2, 2007
WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court ordered the federal government on
Monday to take a fresh look at regulating carbon dioxide emissions from cars, a
rebuke to Bush administration policy on global warming.
In a 5-4 decision, the court said the Clean Air Act gives the Environmental
Protection Agency the authority to regulate the emissions of carbon dioxide and
other greenhouse gases from cars.
Greenhouse gases are air pollutants under the landmark environmental law,
Justice John Paul Stevens said in his majority opinion.
The court’s four conservative justices — Chief Justice John Roberts and
Justices Samuel Alito, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas — dissented.
Many scientists believe greenhouse gases, flowing into the atmosphere at an
unprecedented rate, are leading to a warming of the Earth, rising sea levels and
other marked ecological changes.
The politics of global warming have changed dramatically since the court
agreed last year to hear its first global warming case.
Democrats took control of Congress last November. The world’s leading
climate scientists reported in February that global warming is “very likely”
caused by man and is so severe that it will “continue for centuries.” Former
Vice President Al Gore’s movie, An Inconvenient Truth — making the case for
prompt action on climate change — won an Oscar. Business leaders are saying
they are increasingly open to congressional action to reduce greenhouse gases
emissions, of which carbon dioxide is the largest.
Carbon dioxide is produced when fossil fuels such as oil and natural gas
are burned. One way to reduce those emissions is to have more fuel-efficient
cars.
The court had three questions before it.
—Do states have the right to sue the EPA to challenge its decision?
—Does the Clean Air Act give EPA the authority to regulate tailpipe
emissions of greenhouse gases?
—Does EPA have the discretion not to regulate those emissions?
The court said yes to the first two questions. On the third, it ordered EPA
to re-evaluate its contention it has the discretion not to regulate tailpipe
emissions. The court said the agency has so far provided a “laundry list” of
reasons that include foreign policy considerations.
The majority said the agency must tie its rationale more closely to the
Clean Air Act.
“EPA has offered no reasoned explanation for its refusal to decide whether
greenhouse gases cause or contribute to climate change,” Stevens said. He was
joined by his liberal colleagues, Justices Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg
and David Souter, and the court’s swing voter, Justice Anthony Kennedy.
The lawsuit was filed by 12 states and 13 environmental groups that had
grown frustrated by the Bush administration’s inaction on global warming.
In his dissent, Roberts focused on the issue of standing, whether a party
has the right to file a lawsuit.
The court should simply recognize that redress of the kind of grievances
spelled out by the state of Massachusetts is the function of Congress and the
chief executive, not the federal courts, Roberts said.
His position “involves no judgment on whether global warming exists, what
causes it, or the extent of the problem,” he said.
The decision also is expected to boost California’s prospects for gaining
EPA approval of its own program to limit tailpipe emissions of greenhouse gases.
Federal law considers the state a laboratory on environmental issues and gives
California the right to seek approval of standards that are stricter than
national norms.
|