April 2, 2007
 
Mr. Michael Legel
22023 Allentown Rd.
Tremont, IL 61568
 
Dear Mr. Legel:
 
Thank you for sharing your views regarding the Medicare prescription drug benefit, Medicare Part D.
 
The initial implementation of Medicare Part D can best be described as a disaster. Illinois seniors wanted a prescription drug benefit within Medicare that would lower their drug costs. What they have instead is a program that guarantees the pharmaceutical and insurance industries billions of dollars in profits, while seniors face a confusing set of complex choices and Medicare is prevented from negotiating with pharmaceutical companies for lower drug prices. I believe prescription drug coverage is critically important to seniors, but I could not vote for the law that created this program because the final product negotiated by the President and his allies was so deeply flawed.
 
As Medicare beneficiaries try to evaluate the offers they receive from private insurers, they must study plan formularies, calculate the out-of-pocket costs associated with each plan, and determine which pharmacies are part of each plan’s network. Some beneficiaries have encountered bureaucratic troubles as they attempted to resolve difficulties obtaining needed medications, and telephone calls to Medicare and the private insurance companies have resulted in long wait times and delays in resolving the problems.
 
Approximately 40 percent of seniors are either losing money or gaining little under this program, in part because of the “donut hole,” a $2,850 gap in coverage for those with drug costs in the middle of the program’s range of benefits. In addition, the program doesn’t do enough to help the more than 4 million seniors who have catastrophic costs. These seniors will spend more than $4,000 annually before receiving full coverage of additional costs.
 
Six million poor seniors and people with disabilities have been made worse off by this bill. They previously paid nothing for drugs and will now have to pay co-pays that will increase annually. In addition, the Congressional Budget Office estimates that, under this law, 2.7 million seniors who receive health benefits from a former employer will lose that coverage as a result of Medicare Part D.
 
Though the authors of this law have touted Medicare Part D as a “voluntary benefit,” the program includes a financial penalty for eligible beneficiaries who delay their enrollment. With the initial enrollment period lasting only until May 15, 2006, many beneficiaries felt pressured to sign up for a program they don’t fully understand and which may not provide them significant cost savings.
 
It didn’t have to be this way. Seniors deserve a Medicare drug benefit that is simple, affordable, and guaranteed. I introduced legislation (S. 345) that would offer a nationwide Medicare-delivered prescription drug plan, in addition to - and as a clear and simple alternative to - the 96 private plans that are now available in Illinois. This measure would require the Secretary of Health and Human Services (HHS) to negotiate for lower drug prices on behalf of beneficiaries. The Veterans Administration (VA) already uses this type of negotiating authority and has cut drug prices by as much as 50 percent for our nation’s veterans. The savings from negotiating on behalf of seniors in Medicare could be used to help close the “donut hole” in Medicare coverage.
 
I have also cosponsored legislation (S. 1841) to extend the initial enrollment period for Medicare Part D until the end of 2006, so that beneficiaries can learn more and make the best choice among the options that are available. The measure also would give every beneficiary the opportunity to make a one-time change in plan enrollment at any point in 2006, if they sign up for one plan and later find out that it does not meet their needs.
 
I also introduced a measure (S. 2313) that would protect seniors from increased drug prices and formulary changes after they sign up for a prescription drug plan, by allowing them to choose a new plan if their plan increases any drug price by more than 10% during the year, or changes its formulary to discontinue coverage of a drug. Once they choose a plan, seniors currently are locked in for year while the private insurers can change drug prices or remove a drug from their formularies at any time. That discrepancy is not fair to seniors.
 
Until the program is reformed, I am dedicated to ensuring that beneficiaries receive the information they need to make informed decisions. If you need assistance in choosing a Medicare prescription drug plan, or if you are experiencing difficulty with a plan you have already enrolled in, I encourage you to call the Illinois Senior Health Insurance Program (SHIP) at 1-800-548-9034 to obtain individualized counseling. I will keep your concerns in mind as I continue to fight to improve Medicare Part D.
 
Sincerely,
Richard J. Durbin
United States Senator