|
Duke lacrosse players: Case closed
[Link is Broken]
POSTED: 6:07 a.m. EDT, April 12, 2007
RALEIGH, North Carolina (CNN) — Free of sexual offense and kidnapping
charges, three steely-eyed former lacrosse players at Duke University called
Wednesday for reforms in the justice system and restraint in the media.
“This whole experience has opened my eyes to a world of injustice that I
never knew existed,” said Reade Seligmann, one of the exonerated athletes.
All charges against Seligmann, David Evans and Collin Finnerty were
dismissed, North Carolina Attorney General Roy Cooper announced earlier
Wednesday.
The three were charged after an escort-service dancer accused them of
raping her at a team party in March 2006.
The case prompted national outrage and discussion about racism and the
rowdy behavior of privileged students at a prestigious university.
The accuser, a student at nearby North Carolina Central University, is
black; the three accused men are white.
‘To hell and back’ “All of the men of the Duke University men’s lacrosse
team have gone to hell and back, but I hope, and all of us sincerely hope, it
was not in vain,” Evans said at a news conference where the men and their
families were greeted by prolonged applause.
The players and their attorneys acknowledged that innocent people go to
prison because they can’t afford high-powered legal teams.
“Many people across this country, across this state, would not have the
opportunity that we did, and this could simply have been brushed underneath the
rug just as another case and some innocent person would end up in jail for their
entire life,” Evans said. “It’s just not right.”
Evans also criticized how news reports characterized him and his
teammates.
“A great disservice has been done to the sport of lacrosse, and the
stereotypes aren’t true,” Evans said. “They sell magazines and newspapers, but
they’re not anything that represents us as a sport, as a school, as a university
and as a team. And they are wrong.”
Finnerty thanked his family, friends and fellow students for their support.
Evans’ attorney, Joe Cheshire, admonished the media not to judge suspects
before the legal system does:
“Roy Cooper said a word today; the word is I-N-N-O-C-E-N-T. I wanted to
make sure everybody got that.”
The players and lawyers urged reform in the legal system.
“There seem to be some flaws in the legal system that should be addressed,”
Finnerty said. “The fact that in North Carolina there are no recordings of the
grand jury, and to establish checks and balances on district attorneys.”
State pursuing case against local district attorney In January, Cooper’s
office took over the case from Michael Nifong, the Durham County district
attorney who had been handling it.
“In this case, with the weight of the state behind him, the Durham district
attorney pushed forward unchecked, “Cooper said. “There were many points in this
case where caution would have served justice better than bravado, and in the
rush to condemn a community and a state, [Nifong] lost the ability to see
clearly.”
Asked Nifong’s response to the dismissal of charges, David Freeman, one of
his attorneys, said, “Mr. Nifong recused himself from the case back in January.
The AG’s office reviewed the case for three months, and Nifong had full
confidence in their decision today and stands by it. The process played out as
it should have.”
The North Carolina state bar filed ethics complaints against Nifong in
December and January, accusing him of withholding DNA evidence from the players’
defense attorneys and of “making misrepresentations to the presiding judge.”
Other ethics complaints said Nifong had made inappropriate comments to the
media about evidence, testimony, and the students’ character and credibility.
Regarding the state bar’s ethics investigation, Freeman said, “Today’s
decision is separate from the state bar and should have no bearing on how that
situation will play out.”
Nifong, he said, was in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, working on another
case Wednesday.
Nifong will be tried by the bar in June and could be disbarred if he’s
found guilty, The Associated Press reported.
On Wednesday, defense sources told CNN the defense plans to pursue lawsuits
against Nifong.
The same sources said there were no plans to sue the accuser, who was
described as “a troubled soul.”
Cooper would not comment on possible lawsuits, but said, “I think a lot of
people owe a lot of apologies to other people.”
Case began a year ago The dismissal of the charges ends a yearlong
battle fought in the North Carolina courts.
The allegations of rape, which sparked controversy in the Raleigh-Durham
area and quickly moved into the national spotlight, were made last year when one
of two women hired to dance at a March 13, 2006, party accused the students of
raping her.
The woman initially said the three raped her in a bathroom, but the rape
charges were dropped in December after her story wavered. In addition, two DNA
tests have found no evidence linking any of the three men to their 28-year-old
accuser.
Cooper said inconsistencies in the accuser’s accounts “were so significant
and so contrary to the evidence” that investigators could not conclude that an
attack occurred.
The accuser will not face any charges, Cooper added.
When the case began, Seligmann, of Essex Fells, New Jersey, and Finnerty,
of Garden City, New York, were sophomores. Evans, the team captain, who is from
Bethesda, Maryland, graduated a day before turning himself in to face
charges.
In January, Duke invited Seligmann and Finnerty to return for spring
semester. They had been placed on administrative leave after the dancer made her
accusations. Neither accepted the invitation, according to The Associated
Press.
After Wednesday’s announcement, Duke President Richard Brodhead said he
welcomed the dismissal of the charges, and said Finnerty, Seligmann and Evans
had “carried themselves with dignity through an ordeal of deep
unfairness.”
|