|
Rate freeze bill passes
[Link is Broken] http://www.pjstar.com
Saturday, April 21, 2007
By ADRIANA COLINDRES OF GATEHOUSE NEWS SERVICE
SPRINGFIELD - After a confusing and unexpected twist, the Illinois Senate
on Friday voted to renew an electric rate freeze for customers of the Ameren
Illinois utilities, but not for those served by Chicago-based Commonwealth
Edison. The development sets the stage for another potential deadlock between
the Senate and the House of Representatives about what lawmakers should do to
help consumers who have been hit this year with higher power bills.
In late 2006 and early 2007, the Senate and House approved different plans
meant to ease consumers’ burden, but neither chamber took up the other’s
proposal. The two chambers would have to agree on the same legislation before it
could go to the governor’s desk.
Friday’s 35-20 Senate vote took place shortly after most senators were
caught off-guard by the use of an obscure parliamentary maneuver that basically
erased ComEd from a rate-freeze bill pushed by Sen. Gary Forby, D-Benton.
“I just think I had a fast one pulled on me,” said Forby, who wanted to
include ComEd in the legislation because he believes that would improve its
chances of passage in the House.
Minutes earlier, the Senate voted 33-24 on an amendment to add ComEd to
Forby’s Senate Bill 1592, which would roll back electric rates to their 2006
levels and freeze them for at least a year.
But Sen. Rickey Hendon, a Chicago Democrat allied with Senate President
Emil Jones, filed a “motion to reconsider” the vote on the amendment. Under
Senate rules, filing such a motion means that an amendment is removed from a
bill until senators vote on the motion. The Senate’s presiding officer - either
Jones or one of his assistant majority leaders - would decide when such a vote
could happen.
Sen. James DeLeo, a Chicago Democrat who was presiding over the Senate on
Friday, said a vote on the motion would not take place right away. Forby opted
to go ahead with a vote on what became an Ameren-only rate-freeze bill.
“I didn’t think they would let me move it any other way,” Forby said. “I’d
either have to take part or none.”
As he presented the stripped-down bill for Senate debate, Forby told
colleagues he “never will forget this day.” He predicted the House would add
ComEd to the bill, approve it and send it back to the Senate - and that the
Senate then would kill the bill by not letting it advance any further.
Jones repeatedly has said he opposes reinstating the electric rate freeze
that was part of the state’s 1997 deregulation law and expired earlier this
year.
Sen. Mike Jacobs, D-East Moline, said the Senate Democratic leadership did
Forby a favor by dropping ComEd from the bill.
“Gary Forby’s problem is not with ComEd. Gary’s district’s problem is with
Ameren,” Jacobs said.
Critical reviews
But several other senators criticized the maneuvering that eliminated ComEd
from the freeze legislation.
“This is politics at its worst,” said Senate Republican Leader Frank Watson
of Greenville. “It’s a sad day, and who loses when this kind of charade goes on?
The people.”
“It’s unfortunate that the majority party did not allow us to put ComEd
on,” said Sen. Larry Bomke, R-Springfield. “Clearly, we had the majority (vote)
to do that.”
Sen. Bill Brady, R-Bloomington, said consumers continue to face hardship
because of increased electric rates.
“It’s almost criminal,” Brady said. “We left here over Christmas without a
solution, we left here over Easter without a solution, we’re leaving here now
this weekend without a solution.”
“What we’re doing today is a sham because we know it’s not going to pass,
and it’s not going to become law,” said Sen. Dale Risinger, R-Peoria. “After
today, I’m going to have to go home and take a shower.”
Risinger voted for the freeze legislation. He explained later: “I think at
this point in time, we need to give some relief to the constituents. The problem
is, this won’t do it.”
Sen. David Koehler, D-Peoria, said Forby’s freeze bill would not truly roll
back electric rates. Instead, it would trigger a legal battle in the courts, he
said.
“The freeze is not going to give you any kind of return very soon,” he
said. “A freeze is not the right thing.”
Koehler was the only central Illinois senator to vote against the
legislation.
Ameren issued a news release Friday afternoon, promising to “vigorously
pursue all available legal actions and strategies” if the freeze legislation
becomes law. The Ameren Illinois utility companies are AmerenCIPS, AmerenCILCO
and AmerenIP.
“A rate rollback, refund and freeze does not address the fundamental
problem, but rather is a short-term, feel-good measure that would have
unintended, negative consequences for Illinois, including the loss of real,
immediate relief for the Ameren Illinois utilities’ hardest hit customers,” the
news release said.
Utility negiotiations
Meanwhile, some details finally emerged Friday on the negotiations that
utility companies have conducted with Sen. James Clayborne, D-Belleville, and
others about electricity rates.
Ameren, ComEd and generating companies offered a total $152 million package
to provide immediate relief to customers with the highest power bills, Clayborne
said. That offer was contingent on the state Legislature not passing a rate
freeze.
Most of that money would come from generators, including Exelon and Ameren
Generating, Clayborne said. Of that amount, $72.9 million would have gone to
Ameren customers and $43.7 million to ComEd customers. An additional $35 million
would have been set aside to provide relief in 2008 and 2009.
GateHouse News Service reporter Dana Heupel contributed to this report.
Adriana Colindres can be reached at (217) 782-6292 or adriana.colindres@sj-r.com.com.
|