|
Illinois House votes to ban smoking
[Link is Broken]
By Laura Camper OF GATEHOUSE NEWS SERVICE
SPRINGFIELD - The Illinois House voted 73-42 Tuesday to stamp out smoking
in indoor public places, sending the legislation to Gov. Rod Blagojevich for
what he predicted would be an “enthusiastic” signature. Senate Bill 500, the
Smoke-Free Illinois Act, would ban smoking in almost all indoor public places,
including bars, restaurants and private clubs, beginning Jan. 1, 2008.
If Blagojevich does sign the plan into law, Illinois would become the 19th
state to adopt a comprehensive ban on smoking in indoor public places, according
to the Web site nosmoking.org.
Tobacco stores would be exempt from the ban, as would private rooms in
nursing homes. Hotels and motels would be able to allow smoking in 25 percent of
their rooms.
“Let me see the bill, but it sure sounds to me like that would be something
I would enthusiastically sign,” Blagojevich said at a Chicago appearance earlier
in the day.
The House margin in favor of the ban was surprisingly large, advocates
said.
“I’m shaking from head to foot,” said a thrilled Kathy Drea, director of
public policy for the American Lung Association of Illinois-Iowa. “I just never
expected 73 votes.”
As in most confrontations over indoor smoking, Tuesday’s House debate
centered squarely on the rights of smokers and business owners.
Opponents argued that banning smoking will hurt businesses and that
business owners should be able to make their own decisions about smoking in
their establishments.
However, Rep. Karen Yarbrough, D-Maywood, who sponsored the bill in the
House, said there is no evidence that smoking bans hurt business.
“What does harm business is the patchwork of smoking bans across the
state,” Yarbrough said. “The driving force behind this bill is the businesses in
those towns that currently ban smoking. They are worried that smokers will
patronize other towns. In densely populated areas like those that surround
Chicago, this is a major concern.”
Senate Bill 500 levels the playing field, she said.
Forty-four Illinois communities have approved restrictions on smoking in
public places, according to the American Cancer Society.
“This bill is not about smokers or smokers’ rights,” Yarbrough said. “We’re
talking about a public health issue.”
Quoting statistics from the U.S. Surgeon General, she said secondhand smoke
kills 2,900 people in Illinois each year.
“There is no risk-free level of exposure to secondhand smoke,” Yarbrough
said.
Rep. Aaron Schock, R-Peoria, also considered health risks when he voted for
the smoking ban.
“When somebody chooses to light up in a restaurant, those around them do
not have the liberty, do not have the freedom, to not breathe in that
contaminated air,” Schock said.
But Rep. Mike Bost, R-Murphysboro, argued that people can choose not to
frequent businesses that allow smoking.
“Really, our vote is our dollar bill when it comes to the marketplace,”
Bost said.
But Rep. Dan Brady, a Republican from Bloomington, noted that Bloomington
has enacted its own smoking ban while neighboring towns have not. As a result,
Bloomington businesses have suffered, he said.
“This is an example of where, one time, local control has not worked,”
Brady said.
“When this goes statewide, that argument just goes away,” agreed
Springfield Alderman Bruce Strom, who led a successful effort to ban smoking in
indoor workplaces in Springfield.
Nearby communities have not followed suit, and anecdotal evidence indicates
some restaurants and bars in town without bans have seen an influx of patrons,
while establishments within the city have suffered.
In Peoria, which has no citywide smoking ban, Mayor Jim Ardis has opposed
instituting a local ordinance but said a statewide smoking ban would level the
playing field for most of Illinois.
Local ordinances that are stronger than the proposed statewide standard
would remain in effect, while weaker ordinances would be superseded under the
bill passed Tuesday.
Chicago may be in the latter boat. The Chicago City Council in 2005
approved a phased-in smoking ban for indoor workplaces that gave bars and
taverns until July 1, 2008, to comply but also allowed establishments to opt out
if they installed city-approved air-filtration systems.
Rep. Dave Winters, R-Shirland, brought up concerns that a smoking ban might
increase gang violence at state prisons. That argument was made by the American
Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees when the ban was debated in
a House committee.
“This might be the straw that breaks the camel’s back, and we will lose
control of our prisons,” Winters said.
Yarbrough countered that the county jails are already smoke-free.
“After this bill is signed into law, smokers can smoke in their homes, in
their cars and outside,” Yarbrough said.
Mike Ramsey contributed to this story. Laura Camper can be reached at
217-782-6882 or laura.camper@sj-r.com.
|