|
Retirement Rip-Off
[Link is Broken]
Neil Weinberg 12.11.06
True or false: Your 401(k) plan is costing you more than $1,000
a year. If you can’t answer that question you’re like a lot of Americans.
Caterpillar (nyse: CAT) had a nifty idea for managing its employees’ 401(k)
assets. Instead of bringing in an outside investment firm, the bulldozer
behemoth set up its own, the Preferred Group of Mutual Funds. Caterpillar then
funneled $1.3 billion into it, charging workers fees that were quite ample, if
not out of line with averages in the mutual fund industry: 1.12% annually for a
value fund, 1.54% for an international growth fund and so on.
After a decade and a half of this arrangement Caterpillar this year decided
to dismantle the in-house shop; the assets will presumably wind up with a
mainstream fund vendor. In September lawyers filed a class action against
Caterpillar, charging that the company had used Preferred to profit illegally
from its employees’ retirement accounts, in violation of federal law requiring
that 401(k) plans must solely benefit workers, not their companies. A
Caterpillar spokesman denies wrongdoing and declines further comment.
The Caterpillar suit is one of several filed recently accusing big
corporations, including Boeing (nyse: BA), Kraft (nyse: KFT) and International
Paper (nyse: IP), of failing to offer employees a fair shake in their 401(k)
plans.
The accusations in many of these suits are of this nature: The plan fees
are too high, or the fees are buried deep in disclosure documents where they are
all but impossible to tally or are not revealed at all, or the providers are
tainted by conflicts of interest or even de facto pay-for-play kickbacks.
Such payments are at the center of a suit alleging that General Dynamics
(nyse: GD) let its outside 401(k) administrators secretly move around assets to
benefit themselves rather than employees. Northrop Grumman (nyse: NOC) faces
claims its workers were charged for active management despite investing in
glorified index funds that should have cost them far less. Ten or so such suits,
all filed by the same law firm in St. Louis, Mo., depict the fees as
“complicated and confusing” or “excessive, undisclosed, and illegal.”
The legal assault has sent shivers through some parts of the corporate
world. “These suits are a big deal because, potentially, they apply to every
employer,” says Gregory Ash of law firm Spencer Fane Britt & Browne in
Kansas City, Mo. He defends employers sued under federal ERISA (Employee
Retirement Income Security Act) rules. The new cases “point out the fairly high
degree of ignorance about 401(k) fees,” says Ash, who has received a sharp rise
in calls from firms suddenly jittery about plan liability since the suits
started popping up this year.
Roughly 40 million Americans, or two-thirds of the private-sector workforce
participating in a retirement plan, have only a 401(k). In 1980 that was the
case for only a fifth of workers. Some big companies get competitive bids for
their 401(k) business, landing low-cost funds from Fidelity, Vanguard and other
vendors. But subpar offerings are a common problem at small companies, where
fees often gobble up 2% to 3% of assets each year. For a worker investing in a
conservative blend of stocks and bonds, a 2.5% cost wipes out a significant
fraction—perhaps half—of the real return that can be expected. “Costs in this
industry are way out of line,” says Gregory Carpenter, chief executive of
Employee Fiduciary, a firm that runs 401(k) plans at a fraction of the usual
cost (see box, p. 138).
Small businesses sponsor the majority of the nation’s 650,000 401(k) plans;
97% of such plans have assets of less than $10 million. Because of high fees the
returns on this country’s $2.9 trillion of defined contribution assets lag
behind returns on traditional pension plans by one percentage point a year,
estimates the Center for Retirement Research at Boston College. That one-point
difference equates to $29 billion a year in fees that otherwise might have gone
toward retirement savings.
Why don’t employers shop around for better deals? Partly because their own
money is not at stake. The company may pick up some recordkeeping costs, but the
fees on the underlying funds are almost always borne by the workers. “Employers
have a legal duty to oversee 401(k)s with the same care they do traditional
pensions, but the incentive isn’t there because employees bear the brunt of the
costs,” says Jerome Schlichter, whose firm, Schlichter, Bogard & Denton of
St. Louis, is pushing the spate of recent suits.
And why don’t workers squawk—or, if given choices, go for the cheapest
funds offered? “Fees in these plans are not transparent, and without
transparency it’s hard for employers or participants to come up with low-fee
options,” says Alicia Munnell, director of Boston College’s retirement research
center.
Another problem: Mutual funds peg fees to account balances, which have
tripled in a decade. “The vast majority of plan sponsors [employers] have not
calculated and do not know the actual cost of running the plan,” a U.S. Labor
Department study group noted in 2004. “This ‘out of sight, out of mind’
mentality is particularly dangerous in asset-based fee arrangements, because as
the account balances grow, so do the fees, regardless of whether additional
services are provided.” Officials now are drafting rules to force administrators
to reveal more about the fees.
The outfits vying to run 401(k) plans often do so by offering them at low
or no cost to corporations, only 37% of which pay anything toward their upkeep,
according to Deloitte Consulting. Plan administrators then make up the shortfall
in two ways: by quietly deducting various fees from employees’ accounts; and by
charging mutual funds for shelf space in the plan.
Marty P. VanDriel, general manager of TriVan Truck Body, a custom
truckmaker in Ferndale, Wash., decided earlier this year to set up a 401(k) to
help retain skilled welders and fabricators in a tight labor market. A
stockbroker presented him with a Principal Security Builder Retirement Program.
Principal Financial is the largest operator of small-company 401(k) plans, with
30,000 under management.
Based on the glossy brochures presented to him, VanDriel assumed the total
cost of the plan would be total employer fees of $500 up front and $1,500 a
year. Only when he received a competing bid did he realize his employees also
would pay top dollar for mutual funds under Principal’s plan. Among those listed
was Alliance Capital’s Large-Cap Value fund at 2.29% a year—two and a half
times what a cheaper share class costs.
One reason Principal’s 401(k) fees are so high is that, like many such
plans, they include a 12b-1 commission for the salesman and a “sub-transfer
agent” fee that fund firms pay to Principal. VanDriel says he didn’t understand
that Principal gets paid by the fund firms whose mutual funds it recommends. He
took a pass on its plan.
A Principal 401(k) proposal submitted to a builder in the Southeast with 40
employees was headlined by a $1,000 setup fee and $2,904 flat annual charge. In
the small print on another page of 24 “Assumptions” was the fact that the plan
proposal doesn’t include investment management fees. Another assumption states
“Compensation scale: Dep./asset 100/25 standard H.” Translation: The selling
broker will pocket 1% of the 401(k) assets invested as an upfront “kill
fee”—lingo for bagging a new account—plus 0.25% a year for the life of the
plan. Principal insists it adequately discloses its fees. “It is our policy to
communicate the cost of operating retirement savings plans to our plan sponsor
clients.”
John Walton, who owns a highway construction outfit in Mobile, Ala., set up
a 401(k) for a few dozen employees four years ago with a large insurer. Over
time the firm withdrew outside investment choices, such as Janus and
Oppenheimer, until only its own mutual funds remained in the plan. Walton
eventually realized his workers were paying nearly 3% of assets a year in
expenses and took his business elsewhere.
“With all the hidden fees inside what the mutual funds were charging, half
our returns were going to expenses,” he says.
Bisys, a 401(k) and fund administrator, was accused of misusing $230
million in fees from mutual fund investors by overcharging for recordkeeping
services and then kicking back some of the money to 27 fund advisers. In
September its fund-services arm settled charges filed by the Securities &
Exchange Commission, agreeing to pay $21 million. Bisys and the SEC declined to
name the fund advisers.
As it does with mutual funds outside of retirement plans, Bisys takes
payments from most fund firms in the 401(k) plans it sells, although it won’t
say how much and doesn’t spell out the payments in plan documents. Instead,
Bisys tells employers whose 401(k) plans it runs that it “may receive fees from
funds.” Employees inquisitive enough to dig through Bisys’ 401(k) prospectuses
will find the potentially compromising fees lumped in with other administrative
charges.
Bisys is more explicit with sales agents. One sheet distributed to brokers
who sell its Link inSight 401(k) plan states that American Funds must make up at
least 60% of investment options. “Each product manufacturer constructs its
product to best position itself to be successful in the marketplace and provide
value to the plan sponsor and participants,” Bisys explains in a written
statement. Given that American Funds pays for play on Bisys’ 401(k) menu, it is
a safe bet that the arrangement provides plenty of value to Bisys, too.
|