|
Media myths about the Jena 6
[Link is Broken]
http://news.yahoo.com
By Craig Franklin Wed Oct 24, 4:00 AM ET
Jena, La. - By now, almost everyone in America has heard of Jena, La.,
because they’ve all heard the story of the “Jena 6.” White students hanging
nooses barely punished, a schoolyard fight, excessive punishment for the six
black attackers, racist local officials, public outrage and protests – the
outside media made sure everyone knew the basics. There’s just one
problem: The media got most of the basics wrong. In fact, I have never before
witnessed such a disgrace in professional journalism. Myths replaced facts, and
journalists abdicated their solemn duty to investigate every claim because they
were seduced by a powerfully appealing but false narrative of racial
injustice.
I should know. I live in Jena. My wife has taught at Jena High School for
many years. And most important, I am probably the only reporter who has covered
these events from the very beginning.
The reason the Jena cases have been propelled into the world spotlight is
two-fold: First, because local officials did not speak publicly early on about
the true events of the past year, the media simply formed their stories based on
one-side’s statements – the Jena 6. Second, the media were downright lazy in
their efforts to find the truth. Often, they simply reported what they’d read on
blogs, which expressed only one side of the issue.
The real story of Jena and the Jena 6 is quite different from what the
national media presented. It’s time to set the record straight.
Myth 1: The Whites-Only Tree. There has never been a “whites-only” tree at
Jena High School. Students of all races sat underneath this tree. When a student
asked during an assembly at the start of school last year if anyone could sit
under the tree, it evoked laughter from everyone present – blacks and whites. As
reported by students in the assembly, the question was asked to make a joke and
to drag out the assembly and avoid class.
Myth 2: Nooses a Signal to Black Students. An investigation by school
officials, police, and an FBI agent revealed the true motivation behind the
placing of two nooses in the tree the day after the assembly. According to the
expulsion committee, the crudely constructed nooses were not aimed at black
students. Instead, they were understood to be a prank by three white students
aimed at their fellow white friends, members of the school rodeo team. (The
students apparently got the idea from watching episodes of “Lonesome Dove.”) The
committee further concluded that the three young teens had no knowledge that
nooses symbolize the terrible legacy of the lynchings of countless blacks in
American history. When informed of this history by school officials, they became
visibly remorseful because they had many black friends. Another myth concerns
their punishment, which was not a three-day suspension, but rather nine days at
an alternative facility followed by two weeks of in-school suspension, Saturday
detentions, attendance at Discipline Court, and evaluation by licensed
mental-health professionals. The students who hung the nooses have not publicly
come forward to give their version of events.
Myth 3: Nooses Were a Hate Crime. Although many believe the three white
students should have been prosecuted for a hate crime for hanging the nooses,
the incident did not meet the legal criteria for a federal hate crime. It also
did not meet the standard for Louisiana’s hate-crime statute, and though widely
condemned by all officials, there was no crime to charge the youths with.
Myth 4: DA’s Threat to Black Students. When District Attorney Reed Walters
spoke to Jena High students at an assembly in September, he did not tell black
students that he could make their life miserable with “the stroke of a pen.”
Instead, according to Walters, “two or three girls, white girls, were
chit-chatting on their cellphones or playing with their cellphones right in the
middle of my dissertation. I got a little irritated at them and said, ‘Pay
attention to me. I am right now having to deal with an aggravated rape case
where I’ve got to decide whether the death penalty applies or not.’ I said,
‘Look, I can be your best friend or your worst enemy. With the stroke of a pen I
can make your life miserable so I want you to call me before you do something
stupid.’”
Mr. Walters had been called to the assembly by police, who had been at the
school earlier that day dealing with some students who were causing
disturbances. Teachers and students have confirmed Walters’s version of
events.
Myth 5: The Fair Barn Party Incident. On Dec. 1, 2006, a private party –
not an all-white party as reported – was held at the local community center
called the Fair Barn. Robert Bailey Jr., soon to be one of the Jena 6, came to
the party with others seeking admittance.
When they were denied entrance by the renter of the facility, a white male
named Justin Sloan (not a Jena High student) at the party attacked Bailey and
hit him in the face with his fist. This is reported in witness statements to
police, including the victim, Robert Bailey, Jr.
Months later, Bailey contended he was hit in the head with a beer bottle
and required stitches. No medical records show this ever occurred. Mr. Sloan was
prosecuted for simple battery, which according to Louisiana law, is the proper
charge for hitting someone with a fist.
Myth 6: The “Gotta-Go” Grocery Incident. On Dec. 2, 2006, Bailey and two
other black Jena High students were involved in an altercation at this local
convenience store, stemming from the incident that occurred the night before.
The three were accused by police of jumping a white man as he entered the store
and stealing a shotgun from him. The two parties gave conflicting statements to
police. However, two unrelated eye witnesses of the event gave statements that
corresponded with that of the white male.
Myth 7: The Schoolyard Fight. The event on Dec. 4, 2006 was consistently
labeled a “schoolyard fight.” But witnesses described something much more
horrific. Several black students, including those now known as the Jena 6,
barricaded an exit to the school’s gym as they lay in wait for Justin Barker to
exit. (It remains unclear why Mr. Barker was specifically targeted.)
When Barker tried to leave through another exit, court testimony indicates,
he was hit from behind by Mychal Bell. Multiple witnesses confirmed that Barker
was immediately knocked unconscious and lay on the floor defenseless as several
other black students joined together to kick and stomp him, with most of the
blows striking his head. Police speculate that the motivation for the attack was
related to the racially charged fights that had occurred during the previous
weekend.
Myth 8: The Attack Is Linked to the Nooses. Nowhere in any of the evidence,
including statements by witnesses and defendants, is there any reference to the
noose incident that occurred three months prior. This was confirmed by the
United States attorney for the Western District of Louisiana, Donald Washington,
on numerous occasions.
Myth 9: Mychal Bell’s All-White Jury. While it is true that Mychal Bell was
convicted as an adult by an all-white jury in June (a conviction that was later
overturned with his case sent to juvenile court), the jury selection process was
completely legal and withstood an investigation by the Justice Department’s
Civil Rights Division. Court officials insist that several black residents were
summoned for jury duty, but did not appear.
Myth 10: Jena 6 as Model Youth. While some members were simply caught up in
the moment, others had criminal records. Bell had at least four prior
violent-crime arrests before the December attack, and was on probation during
most of this year.
Myth 11: Jena Is One of the Most Racist Towns in America. Actually, Jena is
a wonderful place to live for both whites and blacks. The media’s distortion and
outright lies concerning the case have given this rural Louisiana town a label
it doesn’t deserve.
Myth 12: Two Levels of Justice. Outside protesters were convinced that the
prosecution of the Jena 6 was proof of a racially biased system of justice. But
the US Justice Department’s investigation found no evidence to support such a
claim. In fact, the percentage of blacks and whites prosecuted matches the
parish’s population statistics.
These are just 12 of many myths that are portrayed as fact in the media
concerning the Jena cases. (A more thorough review of all events can be found at
www.thejenatimes.net – click on
Chronological Order of Events.)
As with the Duke Lacrosse case, the truth about Jena will eventually be
known. But the town of Jena isn’t expecting any apologies from the media. They
will probably never admit their error and have already moved on to the next
“big” story. Meanwhile in Jena, residents are getting back to their regular
routines, where friends are friends regardless of race. Just as it has been all
along.
• Craig Franklin is assistant editor of The Jena Times.
|