Social Security scare tactic old and tired

[Link is Broken] http://www.pekintimes.com

By Bill Knight
Published: Friday, October 26, 2007 10:08 AM CDT
 
Opinion columnist
 
 
The news feature almost wrote itself: Kathleen Casey Kirschlin, born just after midnight on January 1, 1946 - and therefore the very first post-war Baby Boomer - last week filled out the paperwork to start receiving Social Security benefits.
 
The story was easy but lazy - and revived the tired old refrain that Social Security is doomed.
 
Dutifully repeating the familiar scare tactic, writers proclaimed the beginning of a “demographic tsunami,” referred to “looming insolvency,” and asserted as fact that this meant the nation would eventually go “bankrupt.”
 
Baby Boomers aren’t the problem with Americans’ financial future.
 
Economic policy is.
 
And maybe timid representatives.
 
Since the Roosevelt administration’s New Deal some seven decades ago, Social Security was intended to be a supplement provided by working people to those who’ve already worked.
 
It was never an investment plan wherein workers would get out what they put in. Social Security was meant to be something in addition to savings, pensions or retirement hopes beyond counting on the good will of family, friends, church and community.
 
But!
 
Savings! Most U.S. households have adults working two jobs and working overtime when possible, and it’s still difficult to keep up with the cost of living.
 
Saving has become an unattainable luxury for most regular people.
 
Pensions! The federal government has become so compliant to and reliant on Big Business that there’s little to prevent corporations from reneging on pension promises.
 
So, retirement has become just as much an illusion as the fear of a depleted Social Security trust - a fear shamelessly exploited by Big Business and Big Government to get their hands on Social Security.
 
The White House claims that Social Security is staring down a deficit of more than $10 trillion. That’s misleading - and old.
 
George W. Bush himself tried to use the issue when he ran for Congress in Texas in 1978, when he was defeated. According to MSNBC-TV news reports, Bush said Social Security “would go bust in 10 years” unless people could privately choose to invest their money instead of contributing to Social Security.
 
Obviously, he was wrong. Social Security didn’t go bust in 1988, or in 1998, and it won’t in 2008.
 
Others in his administration have tried to paint a gloomy picture. A study from the Department of Treasury midway through his first term - gearing up for the privatization effort to come, perhaps - said Social Security and Medicare are $44 trillion in debt.
 
In fact, the Social Security system’s trustees report that the program’s in pretty good financial condition.
 
They say slight additions of money could maintain current benefit levels for 75 years.
 
But let’s not get ahead ourselves, as Bush and his Wall Street cronies do.
 
The nonpartisan American Academy of Actuaries (AAA) says that over the next 75 years the Social Security shortfall could amount to $3.7 trillion. Not pocket change, even for Rupert Murdoch. However, the AAA adds that Bush and his cohorts are misleading people by claiming that Social Security “is in far worse financial condition than is actually indicated.”
 
Plus, before considering a solution, consider that Bush and gang usually lump together Social Security and Medicare - two distinct and different programs.
 
Even Treasury concedes that of their scary $44 trillion shortfall, 86 percent of it comes from Medicare. Medicare’s costs are mostly propelled not by aging/surviving Baby Boomers, but by skyrocketing health-care costs.
 
Also, the purported shortfall Treasury predicted mostly stems from projections many years in the future - 62 percent of that combined deficit comes after 2077.
 
A solution needn’t be complex. The most complicated may be increasing payroll taxes modestly, cutting benefits slightly, and raising retirement age. The simplest would be to no longer protect taxpayers whose incomes are above $90,000 a year. Earnings above that level don’t pay in to Social Security.
 
That’s right. Increasing the amount of income subject to the Social Security tax - again, now limited to $90,000 - would handle most of the shortfall caused by more beneficiaries and fewer workers.
 
Another suggestion has been to raise the 12.4 percent Social Security payroll tax, paid half-and-half by workers and employers, to 15.9 percent.
 
But Bush and his buddies refuse to require citizens to share in the costs of society - unless it’s the expensive war in Iraq. And Democrats too often cower at the prospect of being fiscally responsible and pay as we go.
 
Bush’s tax cuts for the wealthy already are dramatically reducing revenue, and that’s more frightening than Social Security.
 
What’s left out of the “Look out! Baby Boomer on Board!” scare stories is that - unlike most of the federal government, Social Security is still generating a surplus.
 
Check out the AAA report on protecting Social Security at http://www.actuary.org/newsroom/pdf/social_sept07.pdf
 
Bill Knight is an award-winning journalist who teaches at Western Illinois University. Contact him at bill.knight@hotmail.com.