|
Editorial Oct. 24, 2007
[Link is Broken]
http://www.ptleader.com
THE COMMON PEOPLE
It took common people - farmers, brewers, printers, silversmiths - to write
the U.S. Constitution and its Bill of Rights some 218 years ago. And it looks as
if it’s up to the common people to try to defend those principles.
Somebody has to step up here.
The Bush administration mocks each provision of the Bill of Rights that
protects private citizens from their government, and likewise pushes past
constitutional constraints that protect other branches of government from the
presidency.
Meanwhile, most federal courts equivocate their way to approve most of
these actions, and Congress, even though in control of the opposition party,
dithers and compromises away our basic rights for fear of accusations of being
soft on terror. The media, meanwhile, fawns and yawns its way through this
immense power grab, distracted by the search for another faux pas by Britney
Spears or startling new evidence about who killed Princess Diana.
The good news comes out of 12 jurors in a Dallas courtroom on Monday. The
jury sat and listened for two months to the testimony of federal agents, Israeli
intelligence officers, wiretaps, videotapes and saw thousands of documents
produced by government prosecutors. They worked their way through 197 counts of
charges against a charitable fundraising organization called the Holy Land
Foundation for Relief and Development, a Muslim organization that says it
directs funds to the construction of hospitals and providing food for the poor
in Palestine.
The Bush Administration closed the group down and froze its assets in
December 2001 for supposedly financing terror attacks and murder around the
world. The case against the Holy Land Foundation was the largest prosecution
case by the U.S. government against an Islamic fundraising group.
Instead, a jury of common people told the judge, after two months of
testimony and 19 days of sifting through testimony and evidence, that they were
ready to acquit three of five defendants on almost all charges and could not
reach a verdict on the other defendants or charges. The judge declared a
mistrial and threw the case out.
The U.S. attorney involved said the government will attempt to retry the
case. We’ll see how another group of common people deals with this intricate set
of facts and assumptions in the future.
One must thank God - or Madison, Adams and Jefferson - that the judgment of
common people was written into our Constitution and basic legal codes. It was
done for times like these, when almost every branch of officialdom gets
stampeded into dangerous over-reaction.
Consider:
The man President Bush named to replace the disgraced Alberto Gonzalez as
attorney general, Michael B. Mukasey, is in confirmation hearings in Washington,
D.C. Asked if he thought the president was subject to federal statutes, Mukasey
equivocated that it would depend on “whether what goes outside the statute
nonetheless lies within the authority of the president to defend the country.”
Read those words carefully. In other words, it’s up to Bush to decide which laws
he will obey and which he will ignore if he feels it’s in the national interest.
In fewer words, laws aren’t binding on this president. He is above the law.
This is not really a shocking admission. Instead it’s a plain statement of
how this White House has actually operated since late 2001. It has operated on
the assumption that presidential decisions trump our nation’s laws - even those
designed to constrain presidential power. So far they’ve stared down the few
voices of opposition and gotten away with it.
In spite of the fact that Mukasey lacks the guile to not state the obvious,
it looks as though the Democratic-controlled Congress will amble along and
approve him. That prediction comes after a long and continuing march of
appeasement and caving in to pressure from the White House, despite a lot of
tough talk following the Democrats’ takeover of Congress in the last election.
That takeover, by the way, surprised the Democrats as much as anyone, again
courtesy of the common people who voted that November Tuesday of 2006.
The opposition-controlled Congress also appears on the verge of granting
immunity to huge telephone companies that illegally assisted the Bush
administration’s illegal wiretapping of the phones, cell phones and email of
common American citizens over the past six years. AT&T, Verizon and others
have been sued by customers who claim that the decision of the companies to open
up their internal switching computers to warrantless wiretaps by the National
Security Agency violated federal privacy laws.
The Senate Intelligence Committee, led by Sen. John D. Rockefeller IV,
Democrat of West Virginia, has already passed a bill that would retroactively
grant immunity to those companies from their customers’ lawsuits. The bill would
also add some restrictions on eavesdropping via a secret court, whose rulings
can’t be known because of course they’re secret. House Democrats are resisting
the immunity section - although presenting terms on which they might accept it.
Rockefeller, by the way, is reported to have accepted $42,000 in political
contributions this year alone from executives and lawyers for AT&T and
Verizon.
The Bush administration acts as if it can cajole and manhandle Congress,
apparently with justification. When it runs into a contrary individual it can’t
silence, other tactics come into play.
That’s what former U.S. Ambassador Joe Wilson found in 2002 when he was
about the only credible high-level government official who spoke out prior to
the invasion of Iraq to say the Bush justification that Saddam Hussein had
nuclear weapons appeared to be garbage.
Within days, an effort to destroy Wilson was launched from at least Vice
President Dick Cheney’s office. This included illegally identifying Wilson’s
wife, Valerie Plame Wilson, as an undercover CIA agent. That put in danger her
life and those of her sources in various countries around the world. In her
just-published book, she describes how she was then denied protection by the CIA
and had her federal taxes audited by the IRS. She has since left government
service, becoming a common person again, probably not a minute too soon.
Bush was quick to offer his protection in the Wilson case, however. He
offered it in the form of a commuted sentence in July to Cheney’s chief of
staff, Lewis Libby, who was the only person to be convicted in this case of
outing a CIA agent, for perjury. Now there’s justice.
The wisdom of the people who wrote our nation’s basic legal code remains
intact. Executive power, especially in a time of high passion, must be
restrained. Even the powerful must live within the law. The fact that our
institutions forget this from time to time is a pattern we have seen before.
Ultimately it’s up to the common people to remember that freedom and liberty are
not nouns, but verbs. They require constant vigilance and constant effort.
Eventually little wins by the common people will add up to something
significant.
It would seem there are few other alternatives.
- Scott Wilson
|