04/27/2010

Bullshit Political Form Reply

Aaron Shock is my U.S. Representative in Congress. I don’t like that. I didn’t vote for him and I think he is entirely too immature for the job. Nevertheless he IS my representative. I didn’t write to him asking his opinion of the health care legislation. I want to know what the new laws mean for me. How will they change health care for me and my family. Instead of providing any information about what is current law this guy sends me a rambling letter of half-truths, innuendo and outright lies about what he THINKS about it. I could care less what he thinks, I want him to represent me. Here is the letter he emailed me. I still have no idea what the laws actually say because this egomaniac can’t be bothered to do his job. If he spent one-tenth the amount of time explaining the true facts instead of holding town halls to rant about his political bullshit ... well now we know that’s simply not going to happen is it.

April 26, 2010
Mr. Michael Legel
Tremont, IL

Dear Mr. Legel,

Thank you for contacting me regarding health care reform. I greatly appreciate hearing your views on this important issue which affects every American family.

On March 21, 2010, the U.S. House of Representatives passed two pieces of legislation aimed at changing our health care system: H.R. 3590, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act and H.R. 4872, the Reconciliation Act of 2010 (the Reconciliation Bill). Unfortunately, instead of working in an open and bi-partisan manner to fix our broken health care system, both bills were crafted in private. H.R. 3590 and H.R. 4872 were packed with private negotiations and legislative ploys which have frustrated and angered millions of Americans. At the end of the day, the only real bi-partisan aspect of these bills was the opposition to them, over thirty House Democrats joined every House Republican in voting against both bills. 

I believe that we need to repeal this fundamentally flawed legislation. We need to start over by enacting several common sense reforms that will improve health care access by lowering costs, while not increasing the size and role of government that infringes on our freedom and patient choice. 

The non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) estimates the legislation that President Obama signed into law will cost $938 billion, yet between eight and nine million Americans will lose their employer sponsored coverage. When taking into account the ten year cost of the bills after they have been fully implemented (FY 2014-2023), the price tag rises to $2.6 trillion, and still does not purport to cover every uninsured American. 

I opposed these pieces of legislation for several reasons, including: the huge unfunded mandate cost that the Medicaid expansion will have on the State of Illinois' budget, the over $500 billion in cuts it makes to Medicare programs, the taxes it raises on middle class Illinoisans struggling to make ends meet in this economic recession, and the taxes it imposes on Illinois businesses, both large and small. I support fixing our health care system in a manner that raises the quality of health care, makes health care more affordable, and expands access to uninsured American families and those with pre-existing conditions. 

The Democrats' health care reforms will expand Medicaid, a program that the non-partisan Government Accountability Office (GAO) has labeled as “high-risk”. This comes at a time when the State of Illinois is facing a $13 billion deficit, due in part to the problem it has in paying its current Medicaid obligations. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, the average cost to care for a Medicaid beneficiary is $6,675 per person. The State of Illinois estimates the expansion will add between 400,000 - 600,000 new Medicaid beneficiaries. As a result, this mandatory expansion of Medicaid will cost the State of Illinois more than $1 billion over five years, starting in 2017.

This huge Medicaid expansion comes at a time when doctors are already having a difficult time with the system. According to a 2006 report from the Center for Studying Health System Change, nearly half of all doctors had to limit the number of Medicaid patients they accept, or in some cases, stop taking them altogether due to late payments by states. Adding even more people into a system that is not functioning properly will only make matters worse and will hurt the people it was intended to help: low income individuals who cannot afford private health insurance. 

I believe that people should have the option of purchasing affordable health care for their families, instead of being placed into a Medicaid system that does not meet their needs. That is why I previously introduced an amendment in the House Rules Committee which provided refundable tax credits to families with incomes up to 200% of the federal poverty level ($44,100 for a family of four). These refundable tax credits would have given families trying to make ends meet the ability to purchase health insurance in the individual market. 

For families whose income is above the threshold, my amendment would have provided them with an above-the-line income tax deduction so that they could use pre-tax dollars to pay for their family's health care. The tax credits would be adjusted for inflation and were based on data from the America's Health Insurance Plans 2006 - 2007 survey of nationwide annual premiums. The survey found that in Illinois, the average individual premium was $2,499, while the family premium was $5,438. Unfortunately, the Democratic leadership did not allow a vote on my amendment.

Over the course of the health care debate, I heard from many senior citizens who voiced their concerns regarding potential cuts to Medicare. A second reason I opposed the health care bills was due to the size of the cuts that they made to Medicare programs. In a year when seniors did not receive a cost-of-living increase due to a decision by the Social Security Administration, it is unfortunate that Congress has chosen to cut over half a trillion dollars from Medicare programs, including $135 billion in cuts to the popular Medicare Advantage program. 

There are 120,000 Illinoisans who are currently enrolled in a Medicare Advantage plan. These plans are popular because they offer additional benefits that many traditional Medicare plans do not, such as dental, vision, and catastrophic coverage. The Democrats' health care bill freezes payments in 2011 and begins the cuts in 2012. These cuts will result in millions of seniors losing access to the extra benefits that these plans provide. 

The new law creates the Independent Payment Advisory Board (IPAB), a group of unelected government bureaucrats who will be empowered to make decisions which will impact the health care of millions of seniors. I believe no government bureaucrat should come between you and your doctor, which is why I have co-sponsored legislation which repeals IPAB.

A third reason that I opposed H.R. 3590 and H.R. 4872 was the $17 billion in new taxes it will impose on hard working Americans. Under the terms of the new laws, all individuals, with very limited exceptions, will be required to purchase “acceptable health care coverage” or will be assessed a tax for failing to purchase health insurance. Americans would be fined $750 per person or $2,085 per family per year for failing to buy health insurance, or they would be fined a phased-in rate of 1-2.5% of their taxable income up to the national average of the least expensive plan. Not only does this tax violate Article 1, Section 8 of the U.S. Constitution (the commerce clause), it also places a government bureaucrat between your medical care and your family's health insurance. Additionally, this bill gives the Internal Revenue Service the power to audit every American to ensure they have “acceptable health care coverage.” 

Even though H.R. 3590 and H.R. 4872 have been signed into law, the fight against the colossal government regulation of our health care system continues. On March 23, 2009, I spearheaded a letter to State Attorney General Lisa Madigan, urging her to join other state attorneys general in their multi-state lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of the health care bill. Along with many others, I believe that the health care legislation violates the commerce clause of the Constitution because Congress has no authority to require individuals to buy insurance. This marks the first time the federal government has required Americans to buy a product or face fines and even imprisonment. The letter was also signed by Illinois Representatives Judy Biggert, Peter Roskam, John Shimkus, Tim Johnson, and Don Manzullo. 

These health care bills also create a new marriage penalty by structuring the health care subsidies in a manner that does not take into account the combined income of married people. Under the new laws, health care subsidies are based on a sliding scale when compared to one's income as a percentage of the Federal Poverty Level. Since the Federal Poverty Level for a couple is not twice the size of a single person, the subsides end up punishing couples just for being married. For example, if two unmarried people each make $32,000 per year, they would receive between $6,000 and $10,000 more in subsidies than they would if they were married because their combined income makes them ineligible for subsidies that are given to people with less annual income. In January 2010, I wrote a letter to Speaker Pelosi opposing this provision and asked that it be eliminated from the final health care language. Unfortunately, the Speaker did not honor the request of the over 100 bi-partisan Members who signed the letter. 

Another reason I opposed this legislation was the impact these bills would have on American companies such as Caterpillar (CAT). On March 25, 2010, CAT's Vice President wrote to Congress and informed Members that according to company projections, certain provisions would drive up CAT's health care costs by 20% (over $100 million) in the first year. He also said that the legislation would “put at risk the coverage our current employees and retirees receive.” I believe that companies such as CAT should be given opportunities to continue to offer health care coverage, instead of being penalized for offering benefits that their employees and retirees have come to rely on. By chastising employers such as CAT, Congress has decided to penalize Americans who rely on their employer for their health insurance. 

These bills impose a new $2,000 tax on businesses with at least fifty employees if they do not offer health insurance to their employees and have at least one full time employee who receives a premium tax credit or cost-sharing subsidy. Companies that do offer health coverage but still have an employee who receives a health premium tax credit will be subject to a penalty of $3,000 per employee receiving the credit. These fines will encourage companies to drop their healthcare coverage and pay the fines, instead of offering health insurance that does meet the minimum standards as determined by a government bureaucrat, and thus forces them to pay even more in penalties. I do not support raising taxes on small businesses that create seven out of every ten jobs in our country. 

The health care bills do not prohibit federal funding for elective abortions. This is a dramatic departure from previous federal legislation which prohibited funding for abortions except in cases of rape, incest, or to save the life of the mother. Regardless of where a person stands on the contentious issue of abortion, the compromise of not federally funding elective abortions has been a long standing tradition. The health care bill breaks this compromise, and makes an already controversial bill even more divisive. 

I support commonsense reforms which fix our broken health care system and make health insurance more affordable for all Americans. That is why I am a co-sponsor of H.R. 3970, the Medical Rights and Reform Act. This legislation protects the doctor-patient relationship, ensuring that no Washington bureaucrat comes between you and your doctor. It also provides health care coverage to those with pre-existing conditions and encourages states to create either a sustainable re-insurance program or a high-risk pool. It includes health plan finders, allowing states, small businesses, and others to band together in order to offer lower health insurance and gives individuals the opportunity to buy insurance across state lines. 

After talking with medical practitioners, I am more convinced that any effort to lower the cost of health care must include a revision of our medical liability laws. H.R. 3970 limits non-economic damages so doctors in high-risk specialties do not leave their communities due to unaffordable medical liability premiums. It also incorporates a sliding scale on attorney fees so individuals, not lawyers, are compensated for harm due to medical errors. Finally, it allows judgments over $250,000 to be paid out in monthly annuities so individuals will be able to budget for future expenses.

I am also a co-sponsor of H.R. 2360, the Small Business Health Options Program (SHOP) Act. This legislation would level the playing field for small business owners and employees by providing tax credits in order to offset the high cost of providing coverage for their employees. The SHOP Act would also encourage the creation of voluntary state purchasing pools. This means that self-employed individuals and small businesses can protect themselves from insurers who charge more for minor health problems or who try to exclude coverage due to pre-existing conditions. 

Although millions of Americans opposed the passage of the Democrats' health care bills, the work on health care reform is just beginning. As Congress and the Administration continue to change and implement provisions of the newly enacted health care legislation, I look forward to the opportunity to work with my colleagues in a bi-partisan manner on legislation which keeps taxes low, incorporates medical liability reform, empowers the individual and not the federal government, and protects the doctor-patient relationship. 

Again, thank you for contacting me. Please don't hesitate to communicate with me in the future regarding this, or any other issue. Also, to stay informed on what's happening in Washington, please feel free to sign up for my electronic newsletter, The Schock Report, at www.schock.house.gov.


Sincerely,

Aaron Schock
Member of Congress

comments at www.mjlegel.com