| 56 of 63 |
![]() | ![]() The Last Word | ![]() |
|
Many of you who read this Blog already know that I was a member of UAW Local 974 during our long years of struggle with Caterpillar to get a labor contract during the 1990s. Part of that involvement was in editing and producing a newsletter called The Unionite. I can not begin to tell you the tight rope I walked between Caterpillar, our local union, and our International union trying to keep our members and others informed of what was at stake without burning bridges or creating more harm than good. My good friend Michael T. sent this to me. He found it in an old archive on his computer and forwarded it to me as a memento of that time. It tells a small story about what some of that was like so long ago. It is now only old water beneath a burned bridge I guess.
The Last Word July 1, 1998 I always like to have the last word in any argument or discussion. Just ask anyone who knows me. And I love to cuss and discuss just about anything. In part that is how I ended up with this editing job, it gives me a blank page to express things. But the page isn’t always blank. Sometimes there are margins and borders —— rules —— written and unwritten. Rules. That’s life. For a long time it was advised we shouldn’t get too carried away about attacking Caterpillar because it might "damage our negotiating postures". And since the UAW International was footing the bill it wasn’t too wise to question this "advice". There was never any "advice" about criticizing the UAW International —— I guess that went without saying. As it should be I guess. After all, who wants to pay to have bad things said about them? Some will say (again rightfully) that the union is us and we should be able to criticize if we want. And I follow that line of thought to a point, but then I wonder what good it does to criticize "us" just because we can? Since we now have a labor contract and our local union financial situation is improving somewhat, our local union has agreed to keep The Unionite alive. And since that time we have received a number of letters from various people very critical of the contract we now have and the process by which it was ratified. They are sincere in their criticism of the ratification, the union leadership (both local and international) and other aspects of what they see as a surrender or "sell-out" in our struggle. They ask that we reprint their commentary for all to read. I do not fault their unionism or their intent. I understand their bitterness and frustration. And I have honestly considered reprinting those comments for all to read – I suppose this lashing out at some of our union leaders is justified and we shouldn’t "let them off the hook" so to speak. Or allow everyone to believe everything is rosy now that we have a contract. But then I look at the front page and I wonder if this is the forum to attack ourselves. After all, it is an official UAW publication of our local union and of the press association of our international union. And so this is my compromise. I acknowledge there are a number of people who believe we could have done better in our struggle and that our leadership let us down. I even admit that I was one of those wearing the "Vote No" button and tried to undermine the union leadership in the push to ratify our current contract. So now what? The contract was ratified. Right, wrong or indifferent it is now the language we are working under. Water under the bridge. Spilled milk. Whatever. Our struggle was founded on the principles of solidarity and unionism. We have tried to set an example standing together against the greedy corporation and somehow I don’t see attacking ourselves as a means to further unionism. Could our union be improved. Certainly. Any organization or relationship can be improved. But I think getting involved is the better answer. Run for office yourself, vote for those who represent your views, privately inform others of your views of the particular candidates and/or incumbents. I honestly can see no way we can reform or improve our union by airing our differences publicly. It will take a much more meaningful commitment to make the improvements we need. We must become more active in pro-worker politics, unionism, and personal choices. Make the commitments to vote pro-worker, buy union, become personally involved, and perhaps most importantly —— get others involved. This publication is an extension of the hope we can get others more personally involved in a positive way. When workers stand together they can make a difference —— not only against employers —— but within their unions and communities as well. Communicate, educate, and stand together. [Author's Note] This article was titled "The Last Word" because it was the last page of the issue. I had intended to continue this in future issues. The article was not allowed to be published, so was never actually printed in "The Unionite". The last page was published blank. by Michael Legel |