09/02/2017

Why Are You A Curmudgeon?!

A recent online conversation about my pride in being a Curmudgeon occurred the other day. The discussion was initially about something rather mundane —— whether we should abolish the tradition of tipping wait staff.

My initial stance was decidedly against this practice as a means of reimbursement to the employee. My feeling is that the employer ought to be required to pay a living wage. If patrons wish to provide a gratuity beyond that, it should be a strictly voluntary thing. I don’t think it can effectively be banned without riling people up and I don’t think it should be required; especially if the service is poor.

There was disagreement and as is often the case the disagreement became personal and the topic abandoned amid declarations that I was an unfeeling old coot who would put the local coffee shop or tavern out of business by forcing them to stop profiting by the low wages they paid the employees.

Now any practicing Curmudgeon should periodically do a bit of self examination when presented with this argument. I quickly decided it was the typical misdirection of a person who could not logically support the original topic and tries to make the discussion about me instead of the topic. It happens.

So I chose to go with misdirection and explained what it is to be a Curmudgeon.

A Curmudgeon is usually defined as surly, argumentative, angry, and other negative attributes. Unless of course they are on your side, then they are wise old people who value their independence and aren’t afraid to speak up for the rights of others. Perspective.

As a Curmudgeon I explain my 1st characteristic is usually simple curiosity. It causes me to wonder why things are the way they are and I stick my nose in places that it doesn’t always belong. And often I haven’t determined a “position” as such but my pointed questions often cause combative responses.

Simply asking somebody, “What do you think of single payer health care?” has resulted in the heated response that I must be a lazy liberal, etc. Sadly I really was interested in the personal response because different people have different ideas. Often I am reminded that, “Curiosity killed the cat.”

Next comes the lack of a PC filter. Or at least a very atrophied filter. I am more apt to speak my true feelings and often find myself confused by the sudden anger it generates. Try as I might I can’t seem to frame my words to soothe the situation. I’m not Forrest Gump and I don’t look totally naive so folks take my reply as aggression I guess. If I say I approve or disapprove of something or other it is not usually a declaration of fault finding but a simple statement or question about how you really think or feel. I don’t personally care of you tip your waitress, I just wonder if you do and how much. Etc.

And even when I do decide someone is way off base or not worth the bother. I don’t have a problem saying so. I don’t usually call someone a dumbass but I have been known to use the word ignoranus and they usually don’t get it thus proving my point.

Another aspect is that as a Curmudgeon I have been known to argue both sides of the issue. Sometimes in the same conversation. Because truth doesn’t always take a side. Or at least my version of the truth. We all have our own versions at times. I have been known to leave no tip at all and would have no qualms at all about it. In fact I might respond that he/she should be glad I didn’t try to get them fired and should be happy I let them off easy.

And last, but not least, I evolve as my curiosity gathers more information, as the times change, as I change, and sometimes just because changing my attitude changes the argument. I don’t think I am ever always right or always wrong but I am always me.

And sometimes the best me just smiles and walks away.
And sometimes not.

comments at www.mjlegel.com